tool/src/main/java/org/antlr/tool/Grammar.java

/*
 * [The "BSD license"]
 *  Copyright (c) 2010 Terence Parr
 *  All rights reserved.
 *
 *  Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
 *  modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
 *  are met:
 *  1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
 *      notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
 *  2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
 *      notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
 *      documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
 *  3. The name of the author may not be used to endorse or promote products
 *      derived from this software without specific prior written permission.
 *
 *  THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR ``AS IS'' AND ANY EXPRESS OR
 *  IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES
 *  OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED.
 *  IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHOR BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT,
 *  INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT
 *  NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE,
 *  DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY
 *  THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT
 *  (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF
 *  THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
 */
package org.antlr.tool;

import org.antlr.Tool;
import org.antlr.analysis.DFA;
import org.antlr.analysis.DFAState;
import org.antlr.analysis.LL1Analyzer;
import org.antlr.analysis.LL1DFA;
import org.antlr.analysis.Label;
import org.antlr.analysis.LookaheadSet;
import org.antlr.analysis.NFA;
import org.antlr.analysis.NFAConversionThread;
import org.antlr.analysis.NFAState;
import org.antlr.analysis.NFAToDFAConverter;
import org.antlr.analysis.SemanticContext;
import org.antlr.analysis.Transition;
import org.antlr.codegen.CodeGenerator;
import org.antlr.codegen.Target;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.ANTLRLexer;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.ANTLRParser;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.ANTLRTreePrinter;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.ActionAnalysis;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.DefineGrammarItemsWalker;
import org.antlr.grammar.v3.TreeToNFAConverter;
import org.antlr.misc.Barrier;
import org.antlr.misc.IntSet;
import org.antlr.misc.IntervalSet;
import org.antlr.misc.MultiMap;
import org.antlr.misc.OrderedHashSet;
import org.antlr.misc.Utils;
import org.antlr.runtime.ANTLRReaderStream;
import org.antlr.runtime.ANTLRStringStream;
import org.antlr.runtime.CommonToken;
import org.antlr.runtime.CommonTokenStream;
import org.antlr.runtime.RecognitionException;
import org.antlr.runtime.Token;
import org.antlr.runtime.tree.CommonTreeNodeStream;
import org.stringtemplate.v4.ST;
import org.stringtemplate.v4.STGroup;
import org.stringtemplate.v4.STGroupString;

import java.io.BufferedReader;
import java.io.File;
import java.io.FileNotFoundException;
import java.io.FileReader;
import java.io.IOException;
import java.io.PrintStream;
import java.io.Reader;
import java.io.StreamTokenizer;
import java.io.StringReader;
import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.Arrays;
import java.util.BitSet;
import java.util.Collection;
import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.HashSet;
import java.util.Iterator;
import java.util.LinkedHashMap;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map;
import java.util.Set;
import java.util.Vector;

/** Represents a grammar in memory. */
public class Grammar {
	public static final String SYNPRED_RULE_PREFIX = "synpred";

	public static final String GRAMMAR_FILE_EXTENSION = ".g";

	/** used for generating lexer temp files */
	public static final String LEXER_GRAMMAR_FILE_EXTENSION = ".g";

	public static final int INITIAL_DECISION_LIST_SIZE = 300;
	public static final int INVALID_RULE_INDEX = -1;

	// the various kinds of labels. t=type, id=ID, types+=type ids+=ID
	public static final int RULE_LABEL = 1;
	public static final int TOKEN_LABEL = 2;
	public static final int RULE_LIST_LABEL = 3;
	public static final int TOKEN_LIST_LABEL = 4;
    public static final int CHAR_LABEL = 5; // used in lexer for x='a'
    public static final int WILDCARD_TREE_LABEL = 6; // Used in tree grammar x=.
    public static final int WILDCARD_TREE_LIST_LABEL = 7; // Used in tree grammar x+=.


    public static String[] LabelTypeToString =
		{"<invalid>", "rule", "token", "rule-list", "token-list", "wildcard-tree", "wildcard-tree-list"};

	public static final String ARTIFICIAL_TOKENS_RULENAME = "Tokens";
	public static final String FRAGMENT_RULE_MODIFIER = "fragment";

	public static final String SYNPREDGATE_ACTION_NAME = "synpredgate";

	/** When converting ANTLR char and string literals, here is the
	 *  value set of escape chars.
	 */
	public static int ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue[] = new int[255];

	/** Given a char, we need to be able to show as an ANTLR literal.
	 */
	public static String ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape[] = new String[255];

	static {
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['n'] = '\n';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['r'] = '\r';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['t'] = '\t';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['b'] = '\b';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['f'] = '\f';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['\\'] = '\\';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['\''] = '\'';
		ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue['"'] = '"';
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\n'] = "\\n";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\r'] = "\\r";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\t'] = "\\t";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\b'] = "\\b";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\f'] = "\\f";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\\'] = "\\\\";
		ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape['\''] = "\\'";
	}

	public static final int LEXER = 1;
	public static final int PARSER = 2;
	public static final int TREE_PARSER = 3;
	public static final int COMBINED = 4;
	public static final String[] grammarTypeToString = new String[] {
		"<invalid>",
		"lexer",
		"parser",
		"tree",
		"combined"
	};

	public static final String[] grammarTypeToFileNameSuffix = new String[] {
		"<invalid>",
		"Lexer",
		"Parser",
		"", // no suffix for tree grammars
		"Parser" // if combined grammar, gen Parser and Lexer will be done later
	};

	/** Set of valid imports.  E.g., can only import a tree parser into
	 *  another tree parser.  Maps delegate to set of delegator grammar types.
	 *  validDelegations.get(LEXER) gives list of the kinds of delegators
	 *  that can import lexers.
	 */
	public static MultiMap<Integer,Integer> validDelegations =
		new MultiMap<Integer,Integer>() {
			{
				map(LEXER, LEXER);
				map(LEXER, PARSER);
				map(LEXER, COMBINED);

				map(PARSER, PARSER);
				map(PARSER, COMBINED);

				map(TREE_PARSER, TREE_PARSER);

				// TODO: allow COMBINED
				// map(COMBINED, COMBINED);
			}
		};

	/** This is the buffer of *all* tokens found in the grammar file
	 *  including whitespace tokens etc...  I use this to extract
	 *  lexer rules from combined grammars.
	 */
	public CommonTokenStream tokenBuffer;
	public static final String IGNORE_STRING_IN_GRAMMAR_FILE_NAME = "__";
	public static final String AUTO_GENERATED_TOKEN_NAME_PREFIX = "T__";

	public static class Decision {
		public Grammar grammar;
		public int decision;
		public NFAState startState;
		public GrammarAST blockAST;
		public DFA dfa;
	}

	public class LabelElementPair {
		public Token label;
		public GrammarAST elementRef;
		public String referencedRuleName;
		/** Has an action referenced the label?  Set by ActionAnalysis.g
		 *  Currently only set for rule labels.
		 */
		public boolean actionReferencesLabel;
		public int type; // in {RULE_LABEL,TOKEN_LABEL,RULE_LIST_LABEL,TOKEN_LIST_LABEL}
		public LabelElementPair(Token label, GrammarAST elementRef) {
			this.label = label;
			this.elementRef = elementRef;
			this.referencedRuleName = elementRef.getText();
		}
		public Rule getReferencedRule() {
			return getRule(referencedRuleName);
		}
		@Override
		public String toString() {
			return elementRef.toString();
		}
	}

	/** What name did the user provide for this grammar? */
	public String name;

	/** What type of grammar is this: lexer, parser, tree walker */
	public int type;

	/** A list of options specified at the grammar level such as language=Java.
	 *  The value can be an AST for complicated values such as character sets.
	 *  There may be code generator specific options in here.  I do no
	 *  interpretation of the key/value pairs...they are simply available for
	 *  who wants them.
	 */
	protected Map<String, Object> options;

	public static final Set<String> legalLexerOptions =
			new HashSet<String>() {
				{
				add("language"); add("tokenVocab");
				add("TokenLabelType");
				add("superClass");
				add("filter");
				add("k");
				add("backtrack");
				add("memoize");
				}
			};

	public static final Set<String> legalParserOptions =
			new HashSet<String>() {
				{
				add("language"); add("tokenVocab");
				add("output"); add("rewrite"); add("ASTLabelType");
				add("TokenLabelType");
				add("superClass");
				add("k");
				add("backtrack");
				add("memoize");
				}
			};

    public static final Set<String> legalTreeParserOptions =
        new HashSet<String>() {
            {
                add("language"); add("tokenVocab");
                add("output"); add("rewrite"); add("ASTLabelType");
                add("TokenLabelType");
                add("superClass");
                add("k");
                add("backtrack");
                add("memoize");
                add("filter");
            }
        };

	public static final Set<String> doNotCopyOptionsToLexer =
		new HashSet<String>() {
			{
				add("output"); add("ASTLabelType"); add("superClass");
				add("k"); add("backtrack"); add("memoize"); add("rewrite");
			}
		};

	public static final Map<String, String> defaultOptions =
			new HashMap<String, String>() {
				{
					put("language","Java");
				}
			};

	public static final Set<String> legalBlockOptions =
			new HashSet<String>() {{add("k"); add("greedy"); add("backtrack"); add("memoize");}};

	/** What are the default options for a subrule? */
	public static final Map<String, String> defaultBlockOptions =
			new HashMap<String, String>() {{put("greedy","true");}};

	public static final Map<String, String> defaultLexerBlockOptions =
			new HashMap<String, String>() {{put("greedy","true");}};

	// Token options are here to avoid contaminating Token object in runtime

	/** Legal options for terminal refs like ID&lt;node=MyVarNode&gt; */
	public static final Set<String> legalTokenOptions =
		new HashSet<String>() {
			{
				add(defaultTokenOption);
				add("type");
				add("text");
				add("assoc");
			}
		};

	public static final String defaultTokenOption = "node";

	/** Is there a global fixed lookahead set for this grammar?
	 *  If 0, nothing specified.  -1 implies we have not looked at
	 *  the options table yet to set k.
	 */
	protected int global_k = -1;

	/** Map a scope to a map of name:action pairs.
	 *  Map&lt;String, Map&lt;String,GrammarAST&gt;&gt;
	 *  The code generator will use this to fill holes in the output files.
	 *  I track the AST node for the action in case I need the line number
	 *  for errors.
	 */
	private Map<String, Map<String, Object>> actions =
		new HashMap<String, Map<String, Object>>();

	/** The NFA that represents the grammar with edges labelled with tokens
	 *  or epsilon.  It is more suitable to analysis than an AST representation.
	 */
	public NFA nfa;

	protected NFAFactory factory;

	/** If this grammar is part of a larger composite grammar via delegate
	 *  statement, then this points at the composite.  The composite holds
	 *  a global list of rules, token types, decision numbers, etc...
	 */
	public CompositeGrammar composite;

	/** A pointer back into grammar tree.  Needed so we can add delegates. */
	public CompositeGrammarTree compositeTreeNode;

	/** If this is a delegate of another grammar, this is the label used
	 *  as an instance var by that grammar to point at this grammar. null
	 *  if no label was specified in the delegate statement.
	 */
	public String label;

	/** TODO: hook this to the charVocabulary option */
	protected IntSet charVocabulary = null;

	/** For ANTLRWorks, we want to be able to map a line:col to a specific
	 *  decision DFA so it can display DFA.
	 */
	Map<String, DFA> lineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap = new HashMap<String, DFA>();

	public Tool tool;

	/** The unique set of all rule references in any rule; set of tree node
	 *  objects so two refs to same rule can exist but at different line/position.
	 */
	protected Set<GrammarAST> ruleRefs = new HashSet<GrammarAST>();

	protected Set<GrammarAST> scopedRuleRefs = new HashSet<GrammarAST>();

	/** The unique set of all token ID references in any rule */
	protected Set<Token> tokenIDRefs = new HashSet<Token>();

	/** Be able to assign a number to every decision in grammar;
	 *  decisions in 1..n
	 */
	protected int decisionCount = 0;

	/** A list of all rules that are in any left-recursive cycle.  There
	 *  could be multiple cycles, but this is a flat list of all problematic
	 *  rules. This is stuff we couldn't refactor to precedence rule.
	 */
	protected Set<Rule> leftRecursiveRules;

	/** An external tool requests that DFA analysis abort prematurely.  Stops
	 *  at DFA granularity, which are limited to a DFA size and time computation
	 *  as failsafe.
	 */
	protected boolean externalAnalysisAbort;

	public int numNonLLStar = 0; // hack to track for -report

	/** When we read in a grammar, we track the list of syntactic predicates
	 *  and build faux rules for them later.  See my blog entry Dec 2, 2005:
	 *  http://www.antlr.org/blog/antlr3/lookahead.tml
	 *  This maps the name (we make up) for a pred to the AST grammar fragment.
	 */
	protected LinkedHashMap<String, GrammarAST> nameToSynpredASTMap;

	/** Each left-recursive precedence rule must define precedence array
	 *  for binary operators like:
	 *
	 *  	static int[] e_prec = new int[tokenNames.length];
	 *  	static {
   	 *  		e_prec[75] = 1;
	 *  	}
	 *  Track and we push into parser later; this is computed
	 *  early when we look for prec rules.
	 */
	public List<String> precRuleInitCodeBlocks = new ArrayList<String>();

    /** At least one rule has memoize=true */
    public boolean atLeastOneRuleMemoizes;

    /** At least one backtrack=true in rule or decision or grammar. */
    public boolean atLeastOneBacktrackOption;

	/** Was this created from a COMBINED grammar? */
	public boolean implicitLexer;

	/** Map a rule to it's Rule object */
	protected LinkedHashMap<String,Rule> nameToRuleMap = new LinkedHashMap<String,Rule>();

	/** If this rule is a delegate, some rules might be overridden; don't
	 *  want to gen code for them.
	 */
	public Set<String> overriddenRules = new HashSet<String>();

	/** The list of all rules referenced in this grammar, not defined here,
	 *  and defined in a delegate grammar.  Not all of these will be generated
	 *  in the recognizer for this file; only those that are affected by rule
	 *  definitions in this grammar.  I am not sure the Java target will need
	 *  this but I'm leaving in case other targets need it.
	 *  see NameSpaceChecker.lookForReferencesToUndefinedSymbols()
	 */
	protected Set<Rule> delegatedRuleReferences = new HashSet<Rule>();

	/** The ANTLRParser tracks lexer rules when reading combined grammars
	 *  so we can build the Tokens rule.
	 */
	public List<String> lexerRuleNamesInCombined = new ArrayList<String>();

	/** Track the scopes defined outside of rules and the scopes associated
	 *  with all rules (even if empty).
	 */
	protected Map<String, AttributeScope> scopes = new HashMap<String, AttributeScope>();

	/** An AST that records entire input grammar with all rules.  A simple
	 *  grammar with one rule, "grammar t; a : A | B ;", looks like:
	 * ( grammar t ( rule a ( BLOCK ( ALT A ) ( ALT B ) ) &lt;end-of-rule&gt; ) )
	 */
	protected GrammarAST grammarTree = null;

	/** Each subrule/rule is a decision point and we must track them so we
	 *  can go back later and build DFA predictors for them.  This includes
	 *  all the rules, subrules, optional blocks, ()+, ()* etc...
	 */
	protected Vector<Decision> indexToDecision =
		new Vector<Decision>(INITIAL_DECISION_LIST_SIZE);

	/** If non-null, this is the code generator we will use to generate
	 *  recognizers in the target language.
	 */
	protected CodeGenerator generator;

	public NameSpaceChecker nameSpaceChecker = new NameSpaceChecker(this);

	public LL1Analyzer ll1Analyzer = new LL1Analyzer(this);

	/** For merged lexer/parsers, we must construct a separate lexer spec.
	 *  This is the template for lexer; put the literals first then the
	 *  regular rules.  We don't need to specify a token vocab import as
	 *  I make the new grammar import from the old all in memory; don't want
	 *  to force it to read from the disk.  Lexer grammar will have same
	 *  name as original grammar but will be in different filename.  Foo.g
	 *  with combined grammar will have FooParser.java generated and
	 *  Foo__.g with again Foo inside.  It will however generate FooLexer.java
	 *  as it's a lexer grammar.  A bit odd, but autogenerated.  Can tweak
	 *  later if we want.
	 */
	protected String lexerGrammarTemplate =
			"grammar(name, options, imports, actionNames, actions, literals, rules) ::= <<\n" +
			"lexer grammar <name>;\n" +
			"<if(options)>" +
			"options {\n" +
			"  <options:{it | <it.name>=<it.value>;<\\n>}>\n" +
			"}<\\n>\n" +
			"<endif>\n" +
			"<if(imports)>import <imports; separator=\", \">;<endif>\n" +
			"<actionNames,actions:{n,a|@<n> {<a>\\}\n}>\n" +
			"<literals:{it | <it.ruleName> : <it.literal> ;\n}>\n" +
			"<rules>\n" +
			">>\n";
	protected ST lexerGrammarST;

	/** What file name holds this grammar? */
	protected String fileName;

	/** How long in ms did it take to build DFAs for this grammar?
	 *  If this grammar is a combined grammar, it only records time for
	 *  the parser grammar component.  This only records the time to
	 *  do the LL(*) work; NFA&rarr;DFA conversion.
	 */
	public long DFACreationWallClockTimeInMS;

	public int numberOfSemanticPredicates = 0;
	public int numberOfManualLookaheadOptions = 0;
	public Set<Integer> setOfNondeterministicDecisionNumbers = new HashSet<Integer>();
	public Set<Integer> setOfNondeterministicDecisionNumbersResolvedWithPredicates =
		new HashSet<Integer>();

	/** Track decisions with syn preds specified for reporting.
	 *  This is the a set of BLOCK type AST nodes.
	 */
	public Set<GrammarAST> blocksWithSynPreds = new HashSet<GrammarAST>();

	/** Track decisions that actually use the syn preds in the DFA.
	 *  Computed during NFA to DFA conversion.
	 */
	public Set<DFA> decisionsWhoseDFAsUsesSynPreds = new HashSet<DFA>();

	/** Track names of preds so we can avoid generating preds that aren't used
	 *  Computed during NFA to DFA conversion.  Just walk accept states
	 *  and look for synpreds because that is the only state target whose
	 *  incident edges can have synpreds.  Same is try for
	 *  decisionsWhoseDFAsUsesSynPreds.
	 */
	public Set<String> synPredNamesUsedInDFA = new HashSet<String>();

	/** Track decisions with syn preds specified for reporting.
	 *  This is the a set of BLOCK type AST nodes.
	 */
	public Set<GrammarAST> blocksWithSemPreds = new HashSet<GrammarAST>();

	/** Track decisions that actually use the syn preds in the DFA. */
	public Set<DFA> decisionsWhoseDFAsUsesSemPreds = new HashSet<DFA>();

	protected boolean allDecisionDFACreated = false;

	/** We need a way to detect when a lexer grammar is autogenerated from
	 *  another grammar or we are just sending in a string representing a
	 *  grammar.  We don't want to generate a .tokens file, for example,
	 *  in such cases.
	 */
	protected boolean builtFromString = false;

	/** Factored out the sanity checking code; delegate to it. */
	GrammarSanity sanity = new GrammarSanity(this);

	/** Useful for asking questions about target during analysis */
	Target target;

	/** Create a grammar from file name.  */
	public Grammar(Tool tool, String fileName, CompositeGrammar composite) {
		this.composite = composite;
		setTool(tool);
		setFileName(fileName);
		// ensure we have the composite set to something
		if ( composite.delegateGrammarTreeRoot==null ) {
			composite.setDelegationRoot(this);
		}
		STGroup lexerGrammarSTG = new STGroupString(lexerGrammarTemplate);
		lexerGrammarST = lexerGrammarSTG.getInstanceOf("grammar");
		target = CodeGenerator.loadLanguageTarget((String) getOption("language"));
	}

	/** Useful for when you are sure that you are not part of a composite
	 *  already.  Used in Interp/RandomPhrase and testing.
	 */
	public Grammar() { this((Tool)null); }

	public Grammar(Tool tool) {
		setTool(tool);
		builtFromString = true;
		composite = new CompositeGrammar(this);
		STGroup lexerGrammarSTG = new STGroupString(lexerGrammarTemplate);
		lexerGrammarST = lexerGrammarSTG.getInstanceOf("grammar");
		target = CodeGenerator.loadLanguageTarget((String)getOption("language"));
	}

	/** Used for testing; only useful on noncomposite grammars.*/
	public Grammar(String grammarString)
			throws RecognitionException
	{
		this(null, grammarString);
	}

	/** Used for testing and Interp/RandomPhrase.  Only useful on
	 *  noncomposite grammars.
	 */
	public Grammar(Tool tool, String grammarString)
		throws RecognitionException
	{
		this(tool);
		setFileName("<string>");
		StringReader r = new StringReader(grammarString);
		parseAndBuildAST(r);
		composite.assignTokenTypes();
		//composite.translateLeftRecursiveRules();
		addRulesForSyntacticPredicates();
		composite.defineGrammarSymbols();
		//composite.createNFAs();
		checkNameSpaceAndActions();
	}

	public void setFileName(String fileName) {
		this.fileName = fileName;
	}

	public String getFileName() {
		return fileName;
	}

	public void setName(String name) {
		if ( name==null ) {
			return;
		}
		// don't error check autogenerated files (those with '__' in them)
		String saneFile = fileName.replace('\\', '/');
		int lastSlash = saneFile.lastIndexOf('/');
		String onlyFileName = saneFile.substring(lastSlash+1, fileName.length());
		if ( !builtFromString ) {
			int lastDot = onlyFileName.lastIndexOf('.');
			String onlyFileNameNoSuffix;
			if ( lastDot < 0 ) {
				ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_FILENAME_EXTENSION_ERROR, fileName);
				onlyFileNameNoSuffix = onlyFileName+GRAMMAR_FILE_EXTENSION;
			}
			else {
				onlyFileNameNoSuffix = onlyFileName.substring(0,lastDot);
			}
			if ( !name.equals(onlyFileNameNoSuffix) ) {
				ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_FILE_AND_GRAMMAR_NAME_DIFFER,
								   name,
								   fileName);
			}
		}
		this.name = name;
	}

	public void setGrammarContent(String grammarString) throws RecognitionException {
		StringReader r = new StringReader(grammarString);
		parseAndBuildAST(r);
		composite.assignTokenTypes();
		composite.defineGrammarSymbols();
	}

	public void parseAndBuildAST()
		throws IOException
	{
		FileReader fr;
		BufferedReader br = null;
		try {
			fr = new FileReader(fileName);
			br = new BufferedReader(fr);
			parseAndBuildAST(br);
			br.close();
			br = null;
		}
		finally {
			if ( br!=null ) {
				br.close();
			}
		}
	}

	public void parseAndBuildAST(Reader r) {
		// BUILD AST FROM GRAMMAR
		ANTLRLexer lexer;
		try {
			lexer = new ANTLRLexer(new ANTLRReaderStream(r));
		} catch (IOException e) {
			ErrorManager.internalError("unexpected stream error from parsing "+fileName, e);
			return;
		}

		lexer.setFileName(this.getFileName());
		tokenBuffer = new CommonTokenStream(lexer);
		ANTLRParser parser = ANTLRParser.createParser(tokenBuffer);
		parser.setFileName(this.getFileName());
		ANTLRParser.grammar__return result = null;
		try {
			result = parser.grammar_(this);
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			ErrorManager.internalError("unexpected parser recognition error from "+fileName, re);
		}

        dealWithTreeFilterMode(); // tree grammar and filter=true?

        if ( lexer.hasASTOperator && !buildAST() ) {
			Object value = getOption("output");
			if ( value == null ) {
				ErrorManager.grammarWarning(ErrorManager.MSG_REWRITE_OR_OP_WITH_NO_OUTPUT_OPTION,
										    this, null);
				setOption("output", "AST", null);
			}
			else {
				ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_AST_OP_WITH_NON_AST_OUTPUT_OPTION,
										  this, null, value);
			}
		}

		setGrammarTree(result.getTree());

		//if ( grammarTree!=null ) System.out.println("grammar tree: "+grammarTree.toStringTree());

		grammarTree.setUnknownTokenBoundaries();

		setFileName(lexer.getFileName()); // the lexer #src might change name
		if ( grammarTree.findFirstType(ANTLRParser.RULE)==null ) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_NO_RULES, getFileName());
		}
	}

    protected void dealWithTreeFilterMode() {
        Object filterMode = (String)getOption("filter");
        if ( type==TREE_PARSER && filterMode!=null && filterMode.toString().equals("true") ) {
            // check for conflicting options
            // filter => backtrack=true
            // filter&&output=AST => rewrite=true
            // filter&&output!=AST => error
            // any deviation from valid option set is an error
            Object backtrack = (String)getOption("backtrack");
            Object output = getOption("output");
            Object rewrite = getOption("rewrite");
            if ( backtrack!=null && !backtrack.toString().equals("true") ) {
                ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CONFLICTING_OPTION_IN_TREE_FILTER,
                                   "backtrack", backtrack);
            }
            if ( output!=null && !output.toString().equals("AST") ) {
                ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CONFLICTING_OPTION_IN_TREE_FILTER,
                                   "output", output);
                setOption("output", "", null);
            }
            if ( rewrite!=null && !rewrite.toString().equals("true") ) {
                ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CONFLICTING_OPTION_IN_TREE_FILTER,
                                   "rewrite", rewrite);
            }
            // set options properly
            setOption("backtrack", "true", null);
            if ( output!=null && output.toString().equals("AST") ) {
                setOption("rewrite", "true", null);
            }
            // @synpredgate set to state.backtracking==1 by code gen when filter=true
            // superClass set in template target::treeParser
        }
    }

	public void translateLeftRecursiveRule(GrammarAST ruleAST) {
		//System.out.println(ruleAST.toStringTree());
		CommonTreeNodeStream input = new CommonTreeNodeStream(ruleAST);
		LeftRecursiveRuleAnalyzer leftRecursiveRuleWalker =
			new LeftRecursiveRuleAnalyzer(input, this, ruleAST.enclosingRuleName);
		boolean isLeftRec = false;
		try {
			//System.out.println("TESTING "+ruleAST.enclosingRuleName);
			isLeftRec = leftRecursiveRuleWalker.rec_rule(this);
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_BAD_AST_STRUCTURE, re);
		}
		if ( !isLeftRec ) return;
		List<String> rules = new ArrayList<String>();
		rules.add( leftRecursiveRuleWalker.getArtificialPrecStartRule() ) ;
		rules.add( leftRecursiveRuleWalker.getArtificialOpPrecRule() );
		rules.add( leftRecursiveRuleWalker.getArtificialPrimaryRule() );
		for (String r : rules) {
			GrammarAST t = parseArtificialRule(r);
			addRule(grammarTree, t);
			//System.out.println(t.toStringTree());
		}

		//precRuleInitCodeBlocks.add( precRuleWalker.getOpPrecJavaCode() );
	}

	public void defineGrammarSymbols() {
		if ( Tool.internalOption_PrintGrammarTree ) {
			System.out.println(grammarTree.toStringList());
		}

		// DEFINE RULES
		//System.out.println("### define "+name+" rules");
		DefineGrammarItemsWalker defineItemsWalker = new DefineGrammarItemsWalker(new CommonTreeNodeStream(getGrammarTree()));
		try {
			defineItemsWalker.grammar_(this);
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_BAD_AST_STRUCTURE,
							   re);
		}
	}

	/** ANALYZE ACTIONS, LOOKING FOR LABEL AND ATTR REFS, sanity check */
	public void checkNameSpaceAndActions() {
		examineAllExecutableActions();
		checkAllRulesForUselessLabels();

		nameSpaceChecker.checkConflicts();
	}

	/** Many imports are illegal such as lexer into a tree grammar */
	public boolean validImport(Grammar delegate) {
		List<Integer> validDelegators = validDelegations.get(delegate.type);
		return validDelegators!=null && validDelegators.contains(this.type);
	}

	/** If the grammar is a combined grammar, return the text of the implicit
	 *  lexer grammar.
	 */
	public String getLexerGrammar() {
		if ( lexerGrammarST.getAttribute("literals")==null &&
			 lexerGrammarST.getAttribute("rules")==null )
		{
			// if no rules, return nothing
			return null;
		}
		lexerGrammarST.add("name", name);
		// if there are any actions set for lexer, pass them in
		if ( getActions().get("lexer")!=null ) {
			lexerGrammarST.add("actionNames",
										getActions().get("lexer").keySet());
			lexerGrammarST.add("actions",
										getActions().get("lexer").values());
		}
		// make sure generated grammar has the same options
		if ( options!=null ) {
			for (String optionName : options.keySet()) {
				if ( !doNotCopyOptionsToLexer.contains(optionName) ) {
					Object value = options.get(optionName);
					lexerGrammarST.addAggr("options.{name,value}", optionName, value);
				}
			}
		}
		return lexerGrammarST.render();
	}

	public String getImplicitlyGeneratedLexerFileName() {
		return name+
			   IGNORE_STRING_IN_GRAMMAR_FILE_NAME +
			   LEXER_GRAMMAR_FILE_EXTENSION;
	}

	/** Get the name of the generated recognizer; may or may not be same
	 *  as grammar name.
	 *  Recognizer is TParser and TLexer from T if combined, else
	 *  just use T regardless of grammar type.
	 */
	public String getRecognizerName() {
		String suffix = "";
		List<Grammar> grammarsFromRootToMe = composite.getDelegators(this);
		//System.out.println("grammarsFromRootToMe="+grammarsFromRootToMe);
		String qualifiedName = name;
		if ( grammarsFromRootToMe!=null ) {
			StringBuilder buf = new StringBuilder();
			for (Grammar g : grammarsFromRootToMe) {
				buf.append(g.name);
				buf.append('_');
			}
			buf.append(name);
			qualifiedName = buf.toString();
		}
		if ( type==Grammar.COMBINED ||
			 (type==Grammar.LEXER && implicitLexer) )
		{
			suffix = Grammar.grammarTypeToFileNameSuffix[type];
		}
		return qualifiedName+suffix;
	}

	/** Parse a rule we add artificially that is a list of the other lexer
	 *  rules like this: "Tokens : ID | INT | SEMI ;"  nextToken() will invoke
	 *  this to set the current token.  Add char literals before
	 *  the rule references.
	 *
	 *  If in filter mode, we want every alt to backtrack and we need to
	 *  do k=1 to force the "first token def wins" rule.  Otherwise, the
	 *  longest-match rule comes into play with LL(*).
	 *
	 *  The ANTLRParser antlr.g file now invokes this when parsing a lexer
	 *  grammar, which I think is proper even though it peeks at the info
	 *  that later phases will (re)compute.  It gets a list of lexer rules
	 *  and builds a string representing the rule; then it creates a parser
	 *  and adds the resulting tree to the grammar's tree.
	 */
	public GrammarAST addArtificialMatchTokensRule(GrammarAST grammarAST,
												   List<String> ruleNames,
												   List<String> delegateNames,
												   boolean filterMode) {
		ST matchTokenRuleST;
		if ( filterMode ) {
			matchTokenRuleST = new ST(
					ARTIFICIAL_TOKENS_RULENAME+
					" options {k=1; backtrack=true;} : <rules; separator=\"|\">;");
		}
		else {
			matchTokenRuleST = new ST(
					ARTIFICIAL_TOKENS_RULENAME+" : <rules; separator=\"|\">;");
		}

		// Now add token rule references
		for (int i = 0; i < ruleNames.size(); i++) {
			String rname = ruleNames.get(i);
			matchTokenRuleST.add("rules", rname);
		}
		for (int i = 0; i < delegateNames.size(); i++) {
			String dname = delegateNames.get(i);
			matchTokenRuleST.add("rules", dname+".Tokens");
		}
		//System.out.println("tokens rule: "+matchTokenRuleST.toString());
		GrammarAST r = parseArtificialRule(matchTokenRuleST.render());
		addRule(grammarAST, r);
		//addRule((GrammarAST)parser.getAST());
		//return (GrammarAST)parser.getAST();
		return r;
	}

	public GrammarAST parseArtificialRule(String ruleText) {
		ANTLRLexer lexer = new ANTLRLexer(new ANTLRStringStream(ruleText));
		ANTLRParser parser = ANTLRParser.createParser(new CommonTokenStream(lexer));
		parser.setGrammar(this);
		parser.setGrammarType(this.type);
		try {
			ANTLRParser.rule_return result = parser.rule();
			return result.getTree();
		}
		catch (Exception e) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_ERROR_CREATING_ARTIFICIAL_RULE,
							   e);
			return null;
		}
	}

	public void addRule(GrammarAST grammarTree, GrammarAST t) {
		GrammarAST p = null;
		for (int i = 0; i < grammarTree.getChildCount(); i++ ) {
			p = (GrammarAST)grammarTree.getChild(i);
			if (p == null || p.getType() == ANTLRParser.RULE || p.getType() == ANTLRParser.PREC_RULE) {
				break;
			}
		}

		if (p != null) {
			grammarTree.addChild(t);
		}
	}

	/** for any syntactic predicates, we need to define rules for them; they will get
	 *  defined automatically like any other rule. :)
	 */
	protected List<? extends GrammarAST> getArtificialRulesForSyntacticPredicates(LinkedHashMap<String,GrammarAST> nameToSynpredASTMap)
	{
		List<GrammarAST> rules = new ArrayList<GrammarAST>();
		if ( nameToSynpredASTMap==null ) {
			return rules;
		}
		boolean isLexer = grammarTree.getType()==ANTLRParser.LEXER_GRAMMAR;
		for (Map.Entry<String, GrammarAST> entry : nameToSynpredASTMap.entrySet()) {
			String synpredName = entry.getKey();
			GrammarAST fragmentAST = entry.getValue();
			GrammarAST ruleAST =
				ANTLRParser.createSimpleRuleAST(synpredName,
												fragmentAST,
												isLexer);
			rules.add(ruleAST);
		}
		return rules;
	}

	public void addRulesForSyntacticPredicates() {
		// Get syn pred rules and add to existing tree
		List<? extends GrammarAST> synpredRules =
			getArtificialRulesForSyntacticPredicates(nameToSynpredASTMap);
		for (int i = 0; i < synpredRules.size(); i++) {
			GrammarAST rAST = (GrammarAST) synpredRules.get(i);
			grammarTree.addChild(rAST);
		}
	}

	/** Walk the list of options, altering this Grammar object according
	 *  to any I recognize.
	protected void processOptions() {
		Iterator optionNames = options.keySet().iterator();
		while (optionNames.hasNext()) {
			String optionName = (String) optionNames.next();
			Object value = options.get(optionName);
			if ( optionName.equals("tokenVocab") ) {

			}
		}
	}
	 */

	/** Define all the rule begin/end NFAStates to solve forward reference
	 *  issues.  Critical for composite grammars too.
	 *  This is normally called on all root/delegates manually and then
	 *  buildNFA() is called afterwards because the NFA construction needs
	 *  to see rule start/stop states from potentially every grammar. Has
	 *  to be have these created a priori.  Testing routines will often
	 *  just call buildNFA(), which forces a call to this method if not
	 *  done already. Works ONLY for single noncomposite grammars.
	 */
	public void createRuleStartAndStopNFAStates() {
		//System.out.println("### createRuleStartAndStopNFAStates "+getGrammarTypeString()+" grammar "+name+" NFAs");
		if ( nfa!=null ) {
			return;
		}
		nfa = new NFA(this);
		factory = new NFAFactory(nfa);

		Collection<Rule> rules = getRules();
		for (Rule r : rules) {
			String ruleName = r.name;
			NFAState ruleBeginState = factory.newState();
			ruleBeginState.setDescription("rule "+ruleName+" start");
			ruleBeginState.enclosingRule = r;
			r.startState = ruleBeginState;
			NFAState ruleEndState = factory.newState();
			ruleEndState.setDescription("rule "+ruleName+" end");
			ruleEndState.setAcceptState(true);
			ruleEndState.enclosingRule = r;
			r.stopState = ruleEndState;
		}
	}

	public void buildNFA() {
		if ( nfa==null ) {
			createRuleStartAndStopNFAStates();
		}
		if ( nfa.complete ) {
			// don't let it create more than once; has side-effects
			return;
		}
		//System.out.println("### build "+getGrammarTypeString()+" grammar "+name+" NFAs");
		if ( getRules().isEmpty() ) {
			return;
		}

		CommonTreeNodeStream input = new CommonTreeNodeStream(getGrammarTree());
		TreeToNFAConverter nfaBuilder = new TreeToNFAConverter(input, this, nfa, factory);
		try {
			nfaBuilder.grammar_();
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_BAD_AST_STRUCTURE,
							   name,
							   re);
		}
		nfa.complete = true;
	}

	/** For each decision in this grammar, compute a single DFA using the
	 *  NFA states associated with the decision.  The DFA construction
	 *  determines whether or not the alternatives in the decision are
	 *  separable using a regular lookahead language.
	 *
	 *  Store the lookahead DFAs in the AST created from the user's grammar
	 *  so the code generator or whoever can easily access it.
	 *
	 *  This is a separate method because you might want to create a
	 *  Grammar without doing the expensive analysis.
	 */
	public void createLookaheadDFAs() {
		createLookaheadDFAs(true);
	}

	public void createLookaheadDFAs(boolean wackTempStructures) {
		if ( nfa==null ) {
			buildNFA();
		}

		// CHECK FOR LEFT RECURSION; Make sure we can actually do analysis
		checkAllRulesForLeftRecursion();

		/*
		// was there a severe problem while sniffing the grammar?
		if ( ErrorManager.doNotAttemptAnalysis() ) {
			return;
		}
		*/

		long start = System.currentTimeMillis();

		//System.out.println("### create DFAs");
		int numDecisions = getNumberOfDecisions();
		if ( NFAToDFAConverter.SINGLE_THREADED_NFA_CONVERSION ) {
			for (int decision=1; decision<=numDecisions; decision++) {
				NFAState decisionStartState = getDecisionNFAStartState(decision);
				if ( leftRecursiveRules.contains(decisionStartState.enclosingRule) ) {
					// don't bother to process decisions within left recursive rules.
					if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
						System.out.println("ignoring decision "+decision+
										   " within left-recursive rule "+decisionStartState.enclosingRule.name);
					}
					continue;
				}
				if ( !externalAnalysisAbort && decisionStartState.getNumberOfTransitions()>1 ) {
					Rule r = decisionStartState.enclosingRule;
					if ( r.isSynPred && !synPredNamesUsedInDFA.contains(r.name) ) {
						continue;
					}
					DFA dfa = null;
					// if k=* or k=1, try LL(1)
					if ( getUserMaxLookahead(decision)==0 ||
						 getUserMaxLookahead(decision)==1 )
					{
						dfa = createLL_1_LookaheadDFA(decision);
					}
					if ( dfa==null ) {
						if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
							System.out.println("decision "+decision+
											   " not suitable for LL(1)-optimized DFA analysis");
						}
						dfa = createLookaheadDFA(decision, wackTempStructures);
					}
					if ( dfa.startState==null ) {
						// something went wrong; wipe out DFA
						setLookaheadDFA(decision, null);
					}
					if ( Tool.internalOption_PrintDFA ) {
						System.out.println("DFA d="+decision);
						FASerializer serializer = new FASerializer(nfa.grammar);
						String result = serializer.serialize(dfa.startState);
						System.out.println(result);
					}
				}
			}
		}
		else {
			ErrorManager.info("two-threaded DFA conversion");
			// create a barrier expecting n DFA and this main creation thread
			Barrier barrier = new Barrier(3);
			// assume 2 CPU for now
			int midpoint = numDecisions/2;
			NFAConversionThread t1 =
				new NFAConversionThread(this, barrier, 1, midpoint);
			new Thread(t1).start();
			if ( midpoint == (numDecisions/2) ) {
				midpoint++;
			}
			NFAConversionThread t2 =
				new NFAConversionThread(this, barrier, midpoint, numDecisions);
			new Thread(t2).start();
			// wait for these two threads to finish
			try {
				barrier.waitForRelease();
			}
			catch(InterruptedException e) {
				ErrorManager.internalError("what the hell? DFA interruptus", e);
			}
		}

		long stop = System.currentTimeMillis();
		DFACreationWallClockTimeInMS = stop - start;

		// indicate that we've finished building DFA (even if #decisions==0)
		allDecisionDFACreated = true;
	}

	public DFA createLL_1_LookaheadDFA(int decision) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		String enclosingRule = d.startState.enclosingRule.name;
		Rule r = d.startState.enclosingRule;
		NFAState decisionStartState = getDecisionNFAStartState(decision);

		if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
			System.out.println("--------------------\nattempting LL(1) DFA (d="
							   +decisionStartState.getDecisionNumber()+") for "+
							   decisionStartState.getDescription());
		}

		if ( r.isSynPred && !synPredNamesUsedInDFA.contains(enclosingRule) ) {
			return null;
		}

		// compute lookahead for each alt
		int numAlts = getNumberOfAltsForDecisionNFA(decisionStartState);
		LookaheadSet[] altLook = new LookaheadSet[numAlts+1];
		for (int alt = 1; alt <= numAlts; alt++) {
			int walkAlt =
				decisionStartState.translateDisplayAltToWalkAlt(alt);
			NFAState altLeftEdge = getNFAStateForAltOfDecision(decisionStartState, walkAlt);
			NFAState altStartState = (NFAState)altLeftEdge.transition[0].target;
			//System.out.println("alt "+alt+" start state = "+altStartState.stateNumber);
			altLook[alt] = ll1Analyzer.LOOK(altStartState);
			//System.out.println("alt "+alt+": "+altLook[alt].toString(this));
		}

		// compare alt i with alt j for disjointness
		boolean decisionIsLL_1 = true;
outer:
		for (int i = 1; i <= numAlts; i++) {
			for (int j = i+1; j <= numAlts; j++) {
				/*
				System.out.println("compare "+i+", "+j+": "+
								   altLook[i].toString(this)+" with "+
								   altLook[j].toString(this));
				*/
				LookaheadSet collision = altLook[i].intersection(altLook[j]);
				if ( !collision.isNil() ) {
					//System.out.println("collision (non-LL(1)): "+collision.toString(this));
					decisionIsLL_1 = false;
					break outer;
				}
			}
		}

		boolean foundConfoundingPredicate =
			ll1Analyzer.detectConfoundingPredicates(decisionStartState);
		if ( decisionIsLL_1 && !foundConfoundingPredicate ) {
			// build an LL(1) optimized DFA with edge for each altLook[i]
			if ( NFAToDFAConverter.debug ) {
				System.out.println("decision "+decision+" is simple LL(1)");
			}
			DFA lookaheadDFA = new LL1DFA(decision, decisionStartState, altLook);
			setLookaheadDFA(decision, lookaheadDFA);
			updateLineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap(lookaheadDFA);
			return lookaheadDFA;
		}

		// not LL(1) but perhaps we can solve with simplified predicate search
		// even if k=1 set manually, only resolve here if we have preds; i.e.,
		// don't resolve etc...

		/*
		SemanticContext visiblePredicates =
			ll1Analyzer.getPredicates(decisionStartState);
		boolean foundConfoundingPredicate =
			ll1Analyzer.detectConfoundingPredicates(decisionStartState);
			*/

		// exit if not forced k=1 or we found a predicate situation we
		// can't handle: predicates in rules invoked from this decision.
		if ( getUserMaxLookahead(decision)!=1 || // not manually set to k=1
			 !getAutoBacktrackMode(decision) ||
			 foundConfoundingPredicate )
		{
			//System.out.println("trying LL(*)");
			return null;
		}

		List<IntervalSet> edges = new ArrayList<IntervalSet>();
		for (int i = 1; i < altLook.length; i++) {
			LookaheadSet s = altLook[i];
			edges.add(s.tokenTypeSet);
		}
		List<IntervalSet> disjoint = makeEdgeSetsDisjoint(edges);
		//System.out.println("disjoint="+disjoint);

		MultiMap<IntervalSet, Integer> edgeMap = new MultiMap<IntervalSet, Integer>();
		for (int i = 0; i < disjoint.size(); i++) {
			IntervalSet ds = disjoint.get(i);
			for (int alt = 1; alt < altLook.length; alt++) {
				LookaheadSet look = altLook[alt];
				if ( !ds.and(look.tokenTypeSet).isNil() ) {
					edgeMap.map(ds, alt);
				}
			}
		}
		//System.out.println("edge map: "+edgeMap);

		// TODO: how do we know we covered stuff?

		// build an LL(1) optimized DFA with edge for each altLook[i]
		DFA lookaheadDFA = new LL1DFA(decision, decisionStartState, edgeMap);
		setLookaheadDFA(decision, lookaheadDFA);

		// create map from line:col to decision DFA (for ANTLRWorks)
		updateLineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap(lookaheadDFA);

		return lookaheadDFA;
	}

	private void updateLineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap(DFA lookaheadDFA) {
		GrammarAST decisionAST = nfa.grammar.getDecisionBlockAST(lookaheadDFA.decisionNumber);
		int line = decisionAST.getLine();
		int col = decisionAST.getCharPositionInLine();
		lineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap.put(new StringBuffer().append(line).append(":")
										.append(col).toString(), lookaheadDFA);
	}

	protected List<IntervalSet> makeEdgeSetsDisjoint(List<IntervalSet> edges) {
		OrderedHashSet<IntervalSet> disjointSets = new OrderedHashSet<IntervalSet>();
		// walk each incoming edge label/set and add to disjoint set
		int numEdges = edges.size();
		for (int e = 0; e < numEdges; e++) {
			IntervalSet t = edges.get(e);
			if ( disjointSets.contains(t) ) { // exact set present
				continue;
			}

			// compare t with set i for disjointness
			IntervalSet remainder = t; // remainder starts out as whole set to add
			int numDisjointElements = disjointSets.size();
			for (int i = 0; i < numDisjointElements; i++) {
				IntervalSet s_i = disjointSets.get(i);

				if ( t.and(s_i).isNil() ) { // nothing in common
					continue;
				}
				//System.out.println(label+" collides with "+rl);

				// For any (s_i, t) with s_i&t!=nil replace with (s_i-t, s_i&t)
				// (ignoring s_i-t if nil; don't put in list)

				// Replace existing s_i with intersection since we
				// know that will always be a non nil character class
				IntervalSet intersection = s_i.and(t);
				disjointSets.set(i, intersection);

				// Compute s_i-t to see what is in current set and not in incoming
				IntervalSet existingMinusNewElements = s_i.subtract(t);
				//System.out.println(s_i+"-"+t+"="+existingMinusNewElements);
				if ( !existingMinusNewElements.isNil() ) {
					// found a new character class, add to the end (doesn't affect
					// outer loop duration due to n computation a priori.
					disjointSets.add(existingMinusNewElements);
				}

				// anything left to add to the reachableLabels?
				remainder = t.subtract(s_i);
				if ( remainder.isNil() ) {
					break; // nothing left to add to set.  done!
				}

				t = remainder;
			}
			if ( !remainder.isNil() ) {
				disjointSets.add(remainder);
			}
		}
		return disjointSets.elements();
	}

	public DFA createLookaheadDFA(int decision, boolean wackTempStructures) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		String enclosingRule = d.startState.enclosingRule.name;
		Rule r = d.startState.enclosingRule;

		//System.out.println("createLookaheadDFA(): "+enclosingRule+" dec "+decision+"; synprednames prev used "+synPredNamesUsedInDFA);
		NFAState decisionStartState = getDecisionNFAStartState(decision);
		long startDFA=0,stopDFA;
		if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
			System.out.println("--------------------\nbuilding lookahead DFA (d="
							   +decisionStartState.getDecisionNumber()+") for "+
							   decisionStartState.getDescription());
			startDFA = System.currentTimeMillis();
		}

		DFA lookaheadDFA = new DFA(decision, decisionStartState);
		// Retry to create a simpler DFA if analysis failed (non-LL(*),
		// recursion overflow, or time out).
		boolean failed =
			lookaheadDFA.probe.isNonLLStarDecision() ||
			lookaheadDFA.probe.analysisOverflowed();
		if ( failed && lookaheadDFA.okToRetryDFAWithK1() ) {
			// set k=1 option and try again.
			// First, clean up tracking stuff
			decisionsWhoseDFAsUsesSynPreds.remove(lookaheadDFA);
			// TODO: clean up synPredNamesUsedInDFA also (harder)
			d.blockAST.setBlockOption(this, "k", Utils.integer(1));
			if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
				System.out.print("trying decision "+decision+
								 " again with k=1; reason: "+
								 lookaheadDFA.getReasonForFailure());
			}
			lookaheadDFA = null; // make sure other memory is "free" before redoing
			lookaheadDFA = new DFA(decision, decisionStartState);
		}

		setLookaheadDFA(decision, lookaheadDFA);

		if ( wackTempStructures ) {
			for (DFAState s : lookaheadDFA.getUniqueStates().values()) {
				s.reset();
			}
		}

		// create map from line:col to decision DFA (for ANTLRWorks)
		updateLineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap(lookaheadDFA);

		if ( composite.watchNFAConversion ) {
			stopDFA = System.currentTimeMillis();
			System.out.println("cost: "+lookaheadDFA.getNumberOfStates()+
							   " states, "+(int)(stopDFA-startDFA)+" ms");
		}
		//System.out.println("after create DFA; synPredNamesUsedInDFA="+synPredNamesUsedInDFA);
		return lookaheadDFA;
	}

	/** Terminate DFA creation (grammar analysis).
	 */
	public void externallyAbortNFAToDFAConversion() {
		externalAnalysisAbort = true;
	}

	public boolean NFAToDFAConversionExternallyAborted() {
		return externalAnalysisAbort;
	}

	/** Return a new unique integer in the token type space */
	public int getNewTokenType() {
		composite.maxTokenType++;
		return composite.maxTokenType;
	}

	/** Define a token at a particular token type value.  Blast an
	 *  old value with a new one.  This is called normal grammar processsing
	 *  and during import vocab operations to set tokens with specific values.
	 */
	public void defineToken(String text, int tokenType) {
		//System.out.println("defineToken("+text+", "+tokenType+")");
		if ( composite.tokenIDToTypeMap.get(text)!=null ) {
			// already defined?  Must be predefined one like EOF;
			// do nothing
			return;
		}
		// the index in the typeToTokenList table is actually shifted to
		// hold faux labels as you cannot have negative indices.
		if ( text.charAt(0)=='\'' ) {
			composite.stringLiteralToTypeMap.put(text, Utils.integer(tokenType));
			// track in reverse index too
			if ( tokenType>=composite.typeToStringLiteralList.size() ) {
				composite.typeToStringLiteralList.setSize(tokenType+1);
			}
			composite.typeToStringLiteralList.set(tokenType, text);
		}
		else { // must be a label like ID
			composite.tokenIDToTypeMap.put(text, Utils.integer(tokenType));
		}
		int index = Label.NUM_FAUX_LABELS+tokenType-1;
		//System.out.println("defining "+name+" token "+text+" at type="+tokenType+", index="+index);
		composite.maxTokenType = Math.max(composite.maxTokenType, tokenType);
		if ( index>=composite.typeToTokenList.size() ) {
			composite.typeToTokenList.setSize(index+1);
		}
		String prevToken = composite.typeToTokenList.get(index);
		if ( prevToken==null || prevToken.charAt(0)=='\'' ) {
			// only record if nothing there before or if thing before was a literal
			composite.typeToTokenList.set(index, text);
		}
	}

	/** Define a new rule.  A new rule index is created by incrementing
	 *  ruleIndex.
	 */
	public void defineRule(Token ruleToken,
						   String modifier,
						   Map<String, Object> options,
						   GrammarAST tree,
						   GrammarAST argActionAST,
						   int numAlts)
	{
		String ruleName = ruleToken.getText();
		if ( getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName)!=null ) {
			ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_RULE_REDEFINITION,
									  this, ruleToken, ruleName);
			return;
		}

		if ( (type==Grammar.PARSER||type==Grammar.TREE_PARSER) &&
			 Character.isUpperCase(ruleName.charAt(0)) )
		{
			ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_LEXER_RULES_NOT_ALLOWED,
									  this, ruleToken, ruleName);
			return;
		}

		Rule r = new Rule(this, ruleName, composite.ruleIndex, numAlts);
		/*
		System.out.println("defineRule("+ruleName+",modifier="+modifier+
						   "): index="+r.index+", nalts="+numAlts);
		*/
		r.modifier = modifier;
		nameToRuleMap.put(ruleName, r);
		setRuleAST(ruleName, tree);
		r.setOptions(options, ruleToken);
		r.argActionAST = argActionAST;
		composite.ruleIndexToRuleList.setSize(composite.ruleIndex+1);
		composite.ruleIndexToRuleList.set(composite.ruleIndex, r);
		composite.ruleIndex++;
		if ( ruleName.startsWith(SYNPRED_RULE_PREFIX) ) {
			r.isSynPred = true;
		}
	}

	/** Define a new predicate and get back its name for use in building
	 *  a semantic predicate reference to the syn pred.
	 */
	public String defineSyntacticPredicate(GrammarAST blockAST,
										   String currentRuleName)
	{
		if ( nameToSynpredASTMap==null ) {
			nameToSynpredASTMap = new LinkedHashMap<String, GrammarAST>();
		}
		String predName =
			SYNPRED_RULE_PREFIX+(nameToSynpredASTMap.size() + 1)+"_"+name;
		blockAST.setTreeEnclosingRuleNameDeeply(predName);
		nameToSynpredASTMap.put(predName, blockAST);
		return predName;
	}

	public LinkedHashMap<String, GrammarAST> getSyntacticPredicates() {
		return nameToSynpredASTMap;
	}

	public GrammarAST getSyntacticPredicate(String name) {
		if ( nameToSynpredASTMap==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		return nameToSynpredASTMap.get(name);
	}

	public void synPredUsedInDFA(DFA dfa, SemanticContext semCtx) {
		decisionsWhoseDFAsUsesSynPreds.add(dfa);
		semCtx.trackUseOfSyntacticPredicates(this); // walk ctx looking for preds
	}

	/*
	public Set<Rule> getRuleNamesVisitedDuringLOOK() {
		return rulesSensitiveToOtherRules;
	}
	*/

	/** Given @scope::name {action} define it for this grammar.  Later,
	 *  the code generator will ask for the actions table.  For composite
     *  grammars, make sure header action propogates down to all delegates.
	 */
	public void defineNamedAction(GrammarAST ampersandAST,
								  String scope,
								  GrammarAST nameAST,
								  GrammarAST actionAST)
	{
		if ( scope==null ) {
			scope = getDefaultActionScope(type);
		}
		//System.out.println("Grammar "+name+" define @"+scope+"::"+nameAST.getText()+"{"+actionAST.getText()+"}");
		String actionName = nameAST.getText();
		Map<String, Object> scopeActions = getActions().get(scope);
		if ( scopeActions==null ) {
			scopeActions = new HashMap<String, Object>();
			getActions().put(scope, scopeActions);
		}
		Object a = scopeActions.get(actionName);
		if ( a!=null ) {
			ErrorManager.grammarError(
				ErrorManager.MSG_ACTION_REDEFINITION,this,
				nameAST.getToken(),nameAST.getText());
		}
		else {
			scopeActions.put(actionName,actionAST);
		}
        // propogate header (regardless of scope (lexer, parser, ...) ?
        if ( this==composite.getRootGrammar() && actionName.equals("header") ) {
            List<Grammar> allgrammars = composite.getRootGrammar().getDelegates();
            for (Grammar delegate : allgrammars) {
				if ( target.isValidActionScope(delegate.type, scope) ) {
					//System.out.println("propogate to "+delegate.name);
                	delegate.defineNamedAction(ampersandAST, scope, nameAST, actionAST);
				}
            }
        }
    }

    public void setSynPredGateIfNotAlready(ST gateST) {
        String scope = getDefaultActionScope(type);
        Map<String, Object> actionsForGrammarScope = getActions().get(scope);
        // if no synpredgate action set by user then set
        if ( (actionsForGrammarScope==null ||
             !actionsForGrammarScope.containsKey(Grammar.SYNPREDGATE_ACTION_NAME)) )
        {
            if ( actionsForGrammarScope==null ) {
                actionsForGrammarScope=new HashMap<String, Object>();
                getActions().put(scope, actionsForGrammarScope);
            }
            actionsForGrammarScope.put(Grammar.SYNPREDGATE_ACTION_NAME,
                                       gateST);
        }
    }

	public Map<String, Map<String, Object>> getActions() {
		return actions;
	}

	/** Given a grammar type, what should be the default action scope?
	 *  If I say @members in a COMBINED grammar, for example, the
	 *  default scope should be "parser".
	 */
	public String getDefaultActionScope(int grammarType) {
		switch (grammarType) {
			case Grammar.LEXER :
				return "lexer";
			case Grammar.PARSER :
			case Grammar.COMBINED :
				return "parser";
			case Grammar.TREE_PARSER :
				return "treeparser";
		}
		return null;
	}

	public void defineLexerRuleFoundInParser(Token ruleToken,
											 GrammarAST ruleAST)
	{
//		System.out.println("rule tree is:\n"+ruleAST.toStringTree());
		/*
		String ruleText = tokenBuffer.toOriginalString(ruleAST.ruleStartTokenIndex,
											   ruleAST.ruleStopTokenIndex);
		*/
		// first, create the text of the rule
		StringBuilder buf = new StringBuilder();
		buf.append("// $ANTLR src \"");
		buf.append(getFileName());
		buf.append("\" ");
		buf.append(ruleAST.getLine());
		buf.append("\n");
		for (int i=ruleAST.getTokenStartIndex();
			 i<=ruleAST.getTokenStopIndex() && i<tokenBuffer.size();
			 i++)
		{
			CommonToken t = (CommonToken)tokenBuffer.get(i);
			// undo the text deletions done by the lexer (ugh)
			if ( t.getType()==ANTLRParser.BLOCK ) {
				buf.append("(");
			}
			else if ( t.getType()==ANTLRParser.ACTION ) {
				buf.append("{");
				buf.append(t.getText());
				buf.append("}");
			}
			else if ( t.getType()==ANTLRParser.SEMPRED ||
					  t.getType()==ANTLRParser.SYN_SEMPRED ||
					  t.getType()==ANTLRParser.GATED_SEMPRED ||
					  t.getType()==ANTLRParser.BACKTRACK_SEMPRED )
			{
				buf.append("{");
				buf.append(t.getText());
				buf.append("}?");
			}
			else if ( t.getType()==ANTLRParser.ARG_ACTION ) {
				buf.append("[");
				buf.append(t.getText());
				buf.append("]");
			}
			else {
				buf.append(t.getText());
			}
		}
		String ruleText = buf.toString();
		//System.out.println("[["+ruleText+"]]");
		// now put the rule into the lexer grammar template
		if ( getGrammarIsRoot() ) { // don't build lexers for delegates
			lexerGrammarST.add("rules", ruleText);
		}
		// track this lexer rule's name
		composite.lexerRules.add(ruleToken.getText());
	}

	/** If someone does PLUS='+' in the parser, must make sure we get
	 *  "PLUS : '+' ;" in lexer not "T73 : '+';"
	 */
	public void defineLexerRuleForAliasedStringLiteral(String tokenID,
													   String literal,
													   int tokenType)
	{
		if ( getGrammarIsRoot() ) { // don't build lexers for delegates
			//System.out.println("defineLexerRuleForAliasedStringLiteral: "+literal+" "+tokenType);
			lexerGrammarST.addAggr("literals.{ruleName,type,literal}",
										tokenID,
										Utils.integer(tokenType),
										literal);
		}
		// track this lexer rule's name
		composite.lexerRules.add(tokenID);
	}

	public void defineLexerRuleForStringLiteral(String literal, int tokenType) {
		//System.out.println("defineLexerRuleForStringLiteral: "+literal+" "+tokenType);
		// compute new token name like T237 and define it as having tokenType
		String tokenID = computeTokenNameFromLiteral(tokenType,literal);
		defineToken(tokenID, tokenType);
		// tell implicit lexer to define a rule to match the literal
		if ( getGrammarIsRoot() ) { // don't build lexers for delegates
			lexerGrammarST.addAggr("literals.{ruleName,type,literal}",
										tokenID,
										Utils.integer(tokenType),
										literal);
		}
	}

	public Rule getLocallyDefinedRule(String ruleName) {
		Rule r = nameToRuleMap.get(ruleName);
		return r;
	}

	public Rule getRule(String ruleName) {
		Rule r = composite.getRule(ruleName);
		/*
		if ( r!=null && r.grammar != this ) {
			System.out.println(name+".getRule("+ruleName+")="+r);
		}
		*/
		return r;
	}

	public Rule getRule(String scopeName, String ruleName) {
		if ( scopeName!=null ) { // scope override
			Grammar scope = composite.getGrammar(scopeName);
			if ( scope==null ) {
				return null;
			}
			return scope.getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		}
		return getRule(ruleName);
	}

	public int getRuleIndex(String scopeName, String ruleName) {
		Rule r = getRule(scopeName, ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			return r.index;
		}
		return INVALID_RULE_INDEX;
	}

	public int getRuleIndex(String ruleName) {
		return getRuleIndex(null, ruleName);
	}

	public String getRuleName(int ruleIndex) {
		Rule r = composite.ruleIndexToRuleList.get(ruleIndex);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			return r.name;
		}
		return null;
	}

	/** Should codegen.g gen rule for ruleName?
	 * 	If synpred, only gen if used in a DFA.
	 *  If regular rule, only gen if not overridden in delegator
	 *  Always gen Tokens rule though.
	 */
	public boolean generateMethodForRule(String ruleName) {
		if ( ruleName.equals(ARTIFICIAL_TOKENS_RULENAME) ) {
			// always generate Tokens rule to satisfy lexer interface
			// but it may have no alternatives.
			return true;
		}
		if ( overriddenRules.contains(ruleName) ) {
			// don't generate any overridden rules
			return false;
		}
		// generate if non-synpred or synpred used in a DFA
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		return !r.isSynPred ||
			   (r.isSynPred&&synPredNamesUsedInDFA.contains(ruleName));
	}

	public AttributeScope defineGlobalScope(String name, Token scopeAction) {
		AttributeScope scope = new AttributeScope(this, name, scopeAction);
		scopes.put(name,scope);
		return scope;
	}

	public AttributeScope createReturnScope(String ruleName, Token retAction) {
		AttributeScope scope = new AttributeScope(this, ruleName, retAction);
		scope.isReturnScope = true;
		return scope;
	}

	public AttributeScope createRuleScope(String ruleName, Token scopeAction) {
		AttributeScope scope = new AttributeScope(this, ruleName, scopeAction);
		scope.isDynamicRuleScope = true;
		return scope;
	}

	public AttributeScope createParameterScope(String ruleName, Token argAction) {
		AttributeScope scope = new AttributeScope(this, ruleName, argAction);
		scope.isParameterScope = true;
		return scope;
	}

	/** Get a global scope */
	public AttributeScope getGlobalScope(String name) {
		return scopes.get(name);
	}

	public Map<String, AttributeScope> getGlobalScopes() {
		return scopes;
	}

	/** Define a label defined in a rule r; check the validity then ask the
	 *  Rule object to actually define it.
	 */
	protected void defineLabel(Rule r, Token label, GrammarAST element, int type) {
		boolean err = nameSpaceChecker.checkForLabelTypeMismatch(r, label, type);
		if ( err ) {
			return;
		}
		r.defineLabel(label, element, type);
	}

	public void defineTokenRefLabel(String ruleName,
									Token label,
									GrammarAST tokenRef)
	{
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			if ( type==LEXER &&
				 (tokenRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.CHAR_LITERAL||
				  tokenRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.BLOCK||
				  tokenRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.NOT||
				  tokenRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.CHAR_RANGE||
				  tokenRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.WILDCARD))
			{
				defineLabel(r, label, tokenRef, CHAR_LABEL);
			}
            else {
				defineLabel(r, label, tokenRef, TOKEN_LABEL);
			}
		}
	}

    public void defineWildcardTreeLabel(String ruleName,
                                           Token label,
                                           GrammarAST tokenRef)
    {
        Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
        if ( r!=null ) {
            defineLabel(r, label, tokenRef, WILDCARD_TREE_LABEL);
        }
    }

    public void defineWildcardTreeListLabel(String ruleName,
                                           Token label,
                                           GrammarAST tokenRef)
    {
        Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
        if ( r!=null ) {
            defineLabel(r, label, tokenRef, WILDCARD_TREE_LIST_LABEL);
        }
    }

    public void defineRuleRefLabel(String ruleName,
								   Token label,
								   GrammarAST ruleRef)
	{
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			defineLabel(r, label, ruleRef, RULE_LABEL);
		}
	}

	public void defineTokenListLabel(String ruleName,
									 Token label,
									 GrammarAST element)
	{
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			defineLabel(r, label, element, TOKEN_LIST_LABEL);
		}
	}

	public void defineRuleListLabel(String ruleName,
									Token label,
									GrammarAST element)
	{
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			if ( !r.getHasMultipleReturnValues() ) {
				ErrorManager.grammarError(
					ErrorManager.MSG_LIST_LABEL_INVALID_UNLESS_RETVAL_STRUCT,this,
					label,label.getText());
			}
			defineLabel(r, label, element, RULE_LIST_LABEL);
		}
	}

	/** Given a set of all rewrite elements on right of -&gt;, filter for
	 *  label types such as Grammar.TOKEN_LABEL, Grammar.TOKEN_LIST_LABEL, ...
	 *  Return a displayable token type name computed from the GrammarAST.
	 */
	public Set<String> getLabels(Set<GrammarAST> rewriteElements, int labelType) {
		Set<String> labels = new HashSet<String>();
		for (GrammarAST el : rewriteElements) {
			if ( el.getType()==ANTLRParser.LABEL ) {
				String labelName = el.getText();
				Rule enclosingRule = getLocallyDefinedRule(el.enclosingRuleName);
				if ( enclosingRule==null ) continue;
				LabelElementPair pair = enclosingRule.getLabel(labelName);
                /*
                // if tree grammar and we have a wildcard, only notice it
                // when looking for rule labels not token label. x=. should
                // look like a rule ref since could be subtree.
                if ( type==TREE_PARSER && pair!=null &&
                     pair.elementRef.getType()==ANTLRParser.WILDCARD )
                {
                    if ( labelType==WILDCARD_TREE_LABEL ) {
                        labels.add(labelName);
                        continue;
                    }
                    else continue;
                }
                 */
                // if valid label and type is what we're looking for
				// and not ref to old value val $rule, add to list
				if ( pair!=null && pair.type==labelType &&
					 !labelName.equals(el.enclosingRuleName) )
				{
					labels.add(labelName);
				}
			}
		}
		return labels;
	}

	/** Before generating code, we examine all actions that can have
	 *  $x.y and $y stuff in them because some code generation depends on
	 *  Rule.referencedPredefinedRuleAttributes.  I need to remove unused
	 *  rule labels for example.
	 */
	protected void examineAllExecutableActions() {
		Collection<Rule> rules = getRules();
		for (Rule r : rules) {
			// walk all actions within the rule elements, args, and exceptions
			List<GrammarAST> actions = r.getInlineActions();
			for (int i = 0; i < actions.size(); i++) {
				GrammarAST actionAST = actions.get(i);
				ActionAnalysis sniffer =
					new ActionAnalysis(this, r.name, actionAST);
				sniffer.analyze();
			}
			// walk any named actions like @init, @after
			Collection<? extends Object> namedActions = r.getActions().values();
			for (Object namedAction : namedActions) {
				GrammarAST actionAST = (GrammarAST)namedAction;
				ActionAnalysis sniffer =
					new ActionAnalysis(this, r.name, actionAST);
				sniffer.analyze();
			}
		}
	}

	/** Remove all labels on rule refs whose target rules have no return value.
	 *  Do this for all rules in grammar.
	 */
	public void checkAllRulesForUselessLabels() {
		if ( type==LEXER ) {
			return;
		}
		Set<String> rules = nameToRuleMap.keySet();
		for (String ruleName : rules) {
			Rule r = getRule(ruleName);
			removeUselessLabels(r.getRuleLabels());
			removeUselessLabels(r.getRuleListLabels());
		}
	}

	/** A label on a rule is useless if the rule has no return value, no
	 *  tree or template output, and it is not referenced in an action.
	 */
	protected void removeUselessLabels(Map<String, LabelElementPair> ruleToElementLabelPairMap) {
		if ( ruleToElementLabelPairMap==null ) {
			return;
		}
		Collection<LabelElementPair> labels = ruleToElementLabelPairMap.values();
		List<String> kill = new ArrayList<String>();
		for (LabelElementPair pair : labels) {
			Rule refdRule = getRule(pair.elementRef.getText());
			if ( refdRule!=null && !refdRule.getHasReturnValue() && !pair.actionReferencesLabel ) {
				//System.out.println(pair.label.getText()+" is useless");
				kill.add(pair.label.getText());
			}
		}
		for (int i = 0; i < kill.size(); i++) {
			String labelToKill = kill.get(i);
			// System.out.println("kill "+labelToKill);
			ruleToElementLabelPairMap.remove(labelToKill);
		}
	}

	/** Track a rule reference within an outermost alt of a rule.  Used
	 *  at the moment to decide if $ruleref refers to a unique rule ref in
	 *  the alt.  Rewrite rules force tracking of all rule AST results.
	 *
	 *  This data is also used to verify that all rules have been defined.
	 */
	public void altReferencesRule(String enclosingRuleName,
								  GrammarAST refScopeAST,
								  GrammarAST refAST,
								  int outerAltNum)
	{
		/* Do nothing for now; not sure need; track S.x as x
		String scope = null;
		Grammar scopeG = null;
		if ( refScopeAST!=null ) {
			if ( !scopedRuleRefs.contains(refScopeAST) ) {
				scopedRuleRefs.add(refScopeAST);
			}
			scope = refScopeAST.getText();
		}
		*/
		Rule r = getRule(enclosingRuleName);
		if ( r==null ) {
			return; // no error here; see NameSpaceChecker
		}
		r.trackRuleReferenceInAlt(refAST, outerAltNum);
		Token refToken = refAST.getToken();
		if ( !ruleRefs.contains(refAST) ) {
			ruleRefs.add(refAST);
		}
	}

	/** Track a token reference within an outermost alt of a rule.  Used
	 *  to decide if $tokenref refers to a unique token ref in
	 *  the alt. Does not track literals!
	 *
	 *  Rewrite rules force tracking of all tokens.
	 */
	public void altReferencesTokenID(String ruleName, GrammarAST refAST, int outerAltNum) {
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r==null ) {
			return;
		}
		r.trackTokenReferenceInAlt(refAST, outerAltNum);
		if ( !tokenIDRefs.contains(refAST.getToken()) ) {
			tokenIDRefs.add(refAST.getToken());
		}
	}

	/** To yield smaller, more readable code, track which rules have their
	 *  predefined attributes accessed.  If the rule has no user-defined
	 *  return values, then don't generate the return value scope classes
	 *  etc...  Make the rule have void return value.  Don't track for lexer
	 *  rules.
	 */
	public void referenceRuleLabelPredefinedAttribute(String ruleName) {
		Rule r = getRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null && type!=LEXER ) {
			// indicate that an action ref'd an attr unless it's in a lexer
			// so that $ID.text refs don't force lexer rules to define
			// return values...Token objects are created by the caller instead.
			r.referencedPredefinedRuleAttributes = true;
		}
	}

	public List<? extends Collection<? extends Rule>> checkAllRulesForLeftRecursion() {
		return sanity.checkAllRulesForLeftRecursion();
	}

	/** Return a list of left-recursive rules; no analysis can be done
	 *  successfully on these.  Useful to skip these rules then and also
	 *  for ANTLRWorks to highlight them.
	 */
	public Set<Rule> getLeftRecursiveRules() {
		if ( nfa==null ) {
			buildNFA();
		}
		if ( leftRecursiveRules!=null ) {
			return leftRecursiveRules;
		}
		sanity.checkAllRulesForLeftRecursion();
		return leftRecursiveRules;
	}

	public void checkRuleReference(GrammarAST scopeAST,
								   GrammarAST refAST,
								   GrammarAST argsAST,
								   String currentRuleName)
	{
		sanity.checkRuleReference(scopeAST, refAST, argsAST, currentRuleName);
	}

	/** Rules like "a : ;" and "a : {...} ;" should not generate
	 *  try/catch blocks for RecognitionException.  To detect this
	 *  it's probably ok to just look for any reference to an atom
	 *  that can match some input.  W/o that, the rule is unlikey to have
	 *  any else.
	 */
	public boolean isEmptyRule(GrammarAST block) {
		BitSet nonEmptyTerminals = new BitSet();
		nonEmptyTerminals.set(ANTLRParser.TOKEN_REF);
		nonEmptyTerminals.set(ANTLRParser.STRING_LITERAL);
		nonEmptyTerminals.set(ANTLRParser.CHAR_LITERAL);
		nonEmptyTerminals.set(ANTLRParser.WILDCARD);
		nonEmptyTerminals.set(ANTLRParser.RULE_REF);
		return findFirstTypeOutsideRewrite(block, nonEmptyTerminals) == null;
	}

	protected GrammarAST findFirstTypeOutsideRewrite(GrammarAST block, BitSet types) {
		ArrayList<GrammarAST> worklist = new ArrayList<GrammarAST>();
		worklist.add(block);
		while (!worklist.isEmpty()) {
			GrammarAST current = worklist.remove(worklist.size() - 1);
			if (current.getType() == ANTLRParser.REWRITE) {
				continue;
			}

			if (current.getType() >= 0 && types.get(current.getType())) {
				return current;
			}

			worklist.addAll(Arrays.asList(current.getChildrenAsArray()));
		}

		return null;
	}

	public boolean isAtomTokenType(int ttype) {
		return ttype == ANTLRParser.WILDCARD||
			   ttype == ANTLRParser.CHAR_LITERAL||
			   ttype == ANTLRParser.CHAR_RANGE||
			   ttype == ANTLRParser.STRING_LITERAL||
			   ttype == ANTLRParser.NOT||
			   (type != LEXER && ttype == ANTLRParser.TOKEN_REF);
	}

	public int getTokenType(String tokenName) {
		Integer I;
		if ( tokenName.charAt(0)=='\'') {
			I = composite.stringLiteralToTypeMap.get(tokenName);
		}
		else { // must be a label like ID
			I = composite.tokenIDToTypeMap.get(tokenName);
		}
		int i = (I!=null)? I :Label.INVALID;
		//System.out.println("grammar type "+type+" "+tokenName+"->"+i);
		return i;
	}

	/** Get the list of tokens that are IDs like BLOCK and LPAREN */
	public Set<String> getTokenIDs() {
		return composite.tokenIDToTypeMap.keySet();
	}

	/** Return an ordered integer list of token types that have no
	 *  corresponding token ID like INT or KEYWORD_BEGIN; for stuff
	 *  like 'begin'.
	 */
	public Collection<Integer> getTokenTypesWithoutID() {
		List<Integer> types = new ArrayList<Integer>();
		for (int t =Label.MIN_TOKEN_TYPE; t<=getMaxTokenType(); t++) {
			String name = getTokenDisplayName(t);
			if ( name.charAt(0)=='\'' ) {
				types.add(Utils.integer(t));
			}
		}
		return types;
	}

	/** Get a list of all token IDs and literals that have an associated
	 *  token type.
	 */
	public Set<String> getTokenDisplayNames() {
		Set<String> names = new HashSet<String>();
		for (int t =Label.MIN_TOKEN_TYPE; t <=getMaxTokenType(); t++) {
			names.add(getTokenDisplayName(t));
		}
		return names;
	}

	/** Given a literal like (the 3 char sequence with single quotes) 'a',
	 *  return the int value of 'a'. Convert escape sequences here also.
	 *  ANTLR's antlr.g parser does not convert escape sequences.
	 *
	 *  11/26/2005: I changed literals to always be '...' even for strings.
	 *  This routine still works though.
	 */
	public static int getCharValueFromGrammarCharLiteral(String literal) {
		switch ( literal.length() ) {
			case 3 :
				// 'x'
				return literal.charAt(1); // no escape char
			case 4 :
				// '\x'  (antlr lexer will catch invalid char)
				if ( Character.isDigit(literal.charAt(2)) ) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   "invalid char literal: "+literal);
					return -1;
				}
				int escChar = literal.charAt(2);
				int charVal = ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue[escChar];
				if ( charVal==0 ) {
					// Unnecessary escapes like '\{' should just yield {
					return escChar;
				}
				return charVal;
			case 8 :
				// '\u1234'
				String unicodeChars = literal.substring(3,literal.length()-1);
				return Integer.parseInt(unicodeChars, 16);
			default :
				ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_SYNTAX_ERROR,
								   "invalid char literal: "+literal);
				return -1;
		}
	}

	/** ANTLR does not convert escape sequences during the parse phase because
	 *  it could not know how to print String/char literals back out when
	 *  printing grammars etc...  Someone in China might use the real unicode
	 *  char in a literal as it will display on their screen; when printing
	 *  back out, I could not know whether to display or use a unicode escape.
	 *
	 *  This routine converts a string literal with possible escape sequences
	 *  into a pure string of 16-bit char values.  Escapes and unicode \u0000
	 *  specs are converted to pure chars.  return in a buffer; people may
	 *  want to walk/manipulate further.
	 *
	 *  The NFA construction routine must know the actual char values.
	 */
	public static StringBuffer getUnescapedStringFromGrammarStringLiteral(String literal) {
		//System.out.println("escape: ["+literal+"]");
		StringBuffer buf = new StringBuffer();
		int last = literal.length()-1; // skip quotes on outside
		for (int i=1; i<last; i++) {
			char c = literal.charAt(i);
			if ( c=='\\' ) {
				i++;
				c = literal.charAt(i);
				if ( Character.toUpperCase(c)=='U' ) {
					// \u0000
					i++;
					String unicodeChars = literal.substring(i,i+4);
					// parse the unicode 16 bit hex value
					int val = Integer.parseInt(unicodeChars, 16);
					i+=4-1; // loop will inc by 1; only jump 3 then
					buf.append((char)val);
				}
				else if ( Character.isDigit(c) ) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   "invalid char literal: "+literal);
					buf.append("\\").append(c);
				}
				else {
					buf.append((char)ANTLRLiteralEscapedCharValue[c]); // normal \x escape
				}
			}
			else {
				buf.append(c); // simple char x
			}
		}
		//System.out.println("string: ["+buf.toString()+"]");
		return buf;
	}

	/** Pull your token definitions from an existing grammar in memory.
	 *  You must use Grammar() ctor then this method then setGrammarContent()
	 *  to make this work.  This was useful primarily for testing and
	 *  interpreting grammars until I added import grammar functionality.
	 *  When you import a grammar you implicitly import its vocabulary as well
	 *  and keep the same token type values.
	 *
	 *  Returns the max token type found.
	 */
	public int importTokenVocabulary(Grammar importFromGr) {
		Set<String> importedTokenIDs = importFromGr.getTokenIDs();
		for (String tokenID : importedTokenIDs) {
			int tokenType = importFromGr.getTokenType(tokenID);
			composite.maxTokenType = Math.max(composite.maxTokenType,tokenType);
			if ( tokenType>=Label.MIN_TOKEN_TYPE ) {
				//System.out.println("import token from grammar "+tokenID+"="+tokenType);
				defineToken(tokenID, tokenType);
			}
		}
		return composite.maxTokenType; // return max found
	}

	/** Import the rules/tokens of a delegate grammar. All delegate grammars are
	 *  read during the ctor of first Grammar created.
	 *
	 *  Do not create NFA here because NFA construction needs to hook up with
	 *  overridden rules in delegation root grammar.
	 */
	public void importGrammar(GrammarAST grammarNameAST, String label) {
		String grammarName = grammarNameAST.getText();
		//System.out.println("import "+gfile.getName());
		String gname = grammarName + GRAMMAR_FILE_EXTENSION;
		BufferedReader br = null;
		try {
			String fullName = tool.getLibraryFile(gname);
			FileReader fr = new FileReader(fullName);
			br = new BufferedReader(fr);
			Grammar delegateGrammar;
			delegateGrammar = new Grammar(tool, gname, composite);
			delegateGrammar.label = label;

			addDelegateGrammar(delegateGrammar);

			delegateGrammar.parseAndBuildAST(br);
			delegateGrammar.addRulesForSyntacticPredicates();
			if ( !validImport(delegateGrammar) ) {
				ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_INVALID_IMPORT,
										  this,
										  grammarNameAST.token,
										  this,
										  delegateGrammar);
				return;
			}
			if ( this.type==COMBINED &&
				 (delegateGrammar.name.equals(this.name+grammarTypeToFileNameSuffix[LEXER])||
				  delegateGrammar.name.equals(this.name+grammarTypeToFileNameSuffix[PARSER])) )
			{
				ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_IMPORT_NAME_CLASH,
										  this,
										  grammarNameAST.token,
										  this,
										  delegateGrammar);
				return;
			}
			if ( delegateGrammar.grammarTree!=null ) {
				// we have a valid grammar
				// deal with combined grammars
				if ( delegateGrammar.type == LEXER && this.type == COMBINED ) {
					// ooops, we wasted some effort; tell lexer to read it in
					// later
					lexerGrammarST.add("imports", grammarName);
					// but, this parser grammar will need the vocab
					// so add to composite anyway so we suck in the tokens later
				}
			}
			//System.out.println("Got grammar:\n"+delegateGrammar);
		}
		catch (IOException ioe) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CANNOT_OPEN_FILE,
							   gname,
							   ioe);
		}
		finally {
			if ( br!=null ) {
				try {
					br.close();
				}
				catch (IOException ioe) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CANNOT_CLOSE_FILE,
									   gname,
									   ioe);
				}
			}
		}
	}

	/** add new delegate to composite tree */
	protected void addDelegateGrammar(Grammar delegateGrammar) {
		CompositeGrammarTree t = composite.delegateGrammarTreeRoot.findNode(this);
		t.addChild(new CompositeGrammarTree(delegateGrammar));
		// make sure new grammar shares this composite
		delegateGrammar.composite = this.composite;
	}

	/** Load a vocab file &lt;vocabName&gt;.tokens and return max token type found. */
	public int importTokenVocabulary(GrammarAST tokenVocabOptionAST,
									 String vocabName)
	{
		if ( !getGrammarIsRoot() ) {
			ErrorManager.grammarWarning(ErrorManager.MSG_TOKEN_VOCAB_IN_DELEGATE,
										this,
										tokenVocabOptionAST.token,
										name);
			return composite.maxTokenType;
		}

		File fullFile = tool.getImportedVocabFile(vocabName);
		try {
			FileReader fr = new FileReader(fullFile);
			BufferedReader br = new BufferedReader(fr);
			StreamTokenizer tokenizer = new StreamTokenizer(br);
			tokenizer.parseNumbers();
			tokenizer.wordChars('_', '_');
			tokenizer.eolIsSignificant(true);
			tokenizer.slashSlashComments(true);
			tokenizer.slashStarComments(true);
			tokenizer.ordinaryChar('=');
			tokenizer.quoteChar('\'');
			tokenizer.whitespaceChars(' ',' ');
			tokenizer.whitespaceChars('\t','\t');
			int lineNum = 1;
			int token = tokenizer.nextToken();
			while (token != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOF) {
				String tokenID;
				if ( token == StreamTokenizer.TT_WORD ) {
					tokenID = tokenizer.sval;
				}
				else if ( token == '\'' ) {
					tokenID = "'"+tokenizer.sval+"'";
				}
				else {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_TOKENS_FILE_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   vocabName+CodeGenerator.VOCAB_FILE_EXTENSION,
									   Utils.integer(lineNum));
					while ( tokenizer.nextToken() != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOL ) {}
					token = tokenizer.nextToken();
					continue;
				}
				token = tokenizer.nextToken();
				if ( token != '=' ) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_TOKENS_FILE_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   vocabName+CodeGenerator.VOCAB_FILE_EXTENSION,
									   Utils.integer(lineNum));
					while ( tokenizer.nextToken() != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOL ) {}
					token = tokenizer.nextToken();
					continue;
				}
				token = tokenizer.nextToken(); // skip '='
				if ( token != StreamTokenizer.TT_NUMBER ) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_TOKENS_FILE_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   vocabName+CodeGenerator.VOCAB_FILE_EXTENSION,
									   Utils.integer(lineNum));
					while ( tokenizer.nextToken() != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOL ) {}
					token = tokenizer.nextToken();
					continue;
				}
				int tokenType = (int)tokenizer.nval;
				token = tokenizer.nextToken();
				//System.out.println("import "+tokenID+"="+tokenType);
				composite.maxTokenType = Math.max(composite.maxTokenType,tokenType);
				defineToken(tokenID, tokenType);
				lineNum++;
				if ( token != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOL ) {
					ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_TOKENS_FILE_SYNTAX_ERROR,
									   vocabName+CodeGenerator.VOCAB_FILE_EXTENSION,
									   Utils.integer(lineNum));
					while ( tokenizer.nextToken() != StreamTokenizer.TT_EOL ) {}
					token = tokenizer.nextToken();
					continue;
				}
				token = tokenizer.nextToken(); // skip newline
			}
			br.close();
		}
		catch (FileNotFoundException fnfe) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_CANNOT_FIND_TOKENS_FILE,
							   fullFile);
		}
		catch (IOException ioe) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_ERROR_READING_TOKENS_FILE,
							   fullFile,
							   ioe);
		}
		catch (Exception e) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_ERROR_READING_TOKENS_FILE,
							   fullFile,
							   e);
		}
		return composite.maxTokenType;
	}

	/** Given a token type, get a meaningful name for it such as the ID
	 *  or string literal.  If this is a lexer and the ttype is in the
	 *  char vocabulary, compute an ANTLR-valid (possibly escaped) char literal.
	 */
	public String getTokenDisplayName(int ttype) {
		String tokenName;
		int index;
		// inside any target's char range and is lexer grammar?
		if ( this.type==LEXER &&
			 ttype >= Label.MIN_CHAR_VALUE && ttype <= Label.MAX_CHAR_VALUE )
		{
			return getANTLRCharLiteralForChar(ttype);
		}
		// faux label?
		else if ( ttype<0 ) {
			tokenName = composite.typeToTokenList.get(Label.NUM_FAUX_LABELS+ttype);
		}
		else {
			// compute index in typeToTokenList for ttype
			index = ttype-1; // normalize to 0..n-1
			index += Label.NUM_FAUX_LABELS;     // jump over faux tokens

			if ( index<composite.typeToTokenList.size() ) {
				tokenName = composite.typeToTokenList.get(index);
				if ( tokenName!=null &&
					 tokenName.startsWith(AUTO_GENERATED_TOKEN_NAME_PREFIX) )
				{
					tokenName = composite.typeToStringLiteralList.get(ttype);
				}
			}
			else {
				tokenName = String.valueOf(ttype);
			}
		}
		//System.out.println("getTokenDisplayName ttype="+ttype+", index="+index+", name="+tokenName);
		return tokenName;
	}

	/** Get the list of ANTLR String literals */
	public Set<String> getStringLiterals() {
		return composite.stringLiteralToTypeMap.keySet();
	}

	public String getGrammarTypeString() {
		return grammarTypeToString[type];
	}

	public int getGrammarMaxLookahead() {
		if ( global_k>=0 ) {
			return global_k;
		}
		Object k = getOption("k");
		if ( k==null ) {
			global_k = 0;
		}
		else if (k instanceof Integer) {
			Integer kI = (Integer)k;
			global_k = kI;
		}
		else {
			// must be String "*"
			if ( k.equals("*") ) {  // this the default anyway
				global_k = 0;
			}
		}
		return global_k;
	}

	/** Save the option key/value pair and process it; return the key
	 *  or null if invalid option.
	 */
	public String setOption(String key, Object value, Token optionsStartToken) {
		if ( legalOption(key) ) {
			ErrorManager.grammarError(ErrorManager.MSG_ILLEGAL_OPTION,
									  this,
									  optionsStartToken,
									  key);
			return null;
		}
		if ( !optionIsValid(key, value) ) {
			return null;
		}
        if ( key.equals("backtrack") && value.toString().equals("true") ) {
            composite.getRootGrammar().atLeastOneBacktrackOption = true;
        }
        if ( options==null ) {
			options = new HashMap<String, Object>();
		}
		options.put(key, value);
		return key;
	}

	public boolean legalOption(String key) {
		switch ( type ) {
			case LEXER :
				return !legalLexerOptions.contains(key);
			case PARSER :
				return !legalParserOptions.contains(key);
			case TREE_PARSER :
				return !legalTreeParserOptions.contains(key);
			default :
				return !legalParserOptions.contains(key);
		}
	}

	public void setOptions(Map<String, Object> options, Token optionsStartToken) {
		if ( options==null ) {
			this.options = null;
			return;
		}
		Set<String> keys = options.keySet();
		for (Iterator<String> it = keys.iterator(); it.hasNext();) {
			String optionName = it.next();
			Object optionValue = options.get(optionName);
			String stored=setOption(optionName, optionValue, optionsStartToken);
			if ( stored==null ) {
				it.remove();
			}
		}
	}

	public Object getOption(String key) {
		return composite.getOption(key);
	}

	public Object getLocallyDefinedOption(String key) {
		Object value = null;
		if ( options!=null ) {
			value = options.get(key);
		}
		if ( value==null ) {
			value = defaultOptions.get(key);
		}
		return value;
	}

	public Object getBlockOption(GrammarAST blockAST, String key) {
		String v = (String)blockAST.getBlockOption(key);
		if ( v!=null ) {
			return v;
		}
		if ( type==Grammar.LEXER ) {
			return defaultLexerBlockOptions.get(key);
		}
		return defaultBlockOptions.get(key);
	}

	public int getUserMaxLookahead(int decision) {
		int user_k = 0;
		GrammarAST blockAST = nfa.grammar.getDecisionBlockAST(decision);
		Object k = blockAST.getBlockOption("k");
		if ( k==null ) {
			user_k = nfa.grammar.getGrammarMaxLookahead();
			return user_k;
		}
		if (k instanceof Integer) {
			Integer kI = (Integer)k;
			user_k = kI;
		}
		else {
			// must be String "*"
			if ( k.equals("*") ) {
				user_k = 0;
			}
		}
		return user_k;
	}

	public boolean getAutoBacktrackMode(int decision) {
		NFAState decisionNFAStartState = getDecisionNFAStartState(decision);
		String autoBacktrack =
			(String)getBlockOption(decisionNFAStartState.associatedASTNode, "backtrack");

		if ( autoBacktrack==null ) {
			autoBacktrack = (String)nfa.grammar.getOption("backtrack");
		}
		return autoBacktrack!=null&&autoBacktrack.equals("true");
	}

	public boolean optionIsValid(String key, Object value) {
		return true;
	}

	public boolean buildAST() {
		String outputType = (String)getOption("output");
		if ( outputType!=null ) {
			return outputType.toString().equals("AST");
		}
		return false;
	}

	public boolean rewriteMode() {
		Object outputType = getOption("rewrite");
		if ( outputType!=null ) {
			return outputType.toString().equals("true");
		}
		return false;
	}

	public boolean isBuiltFromString() {
		return builtFromString;
	}

	public boolean buildTemplate() {
		String outputType = (String)getOption("output");
		if ( outputType!=null ) {
			return outputType.toString().equals("template");
		}
		return false;
	}

	public Collection<Rule> getRules() {
		return nameToRuleMap.values();
	}

	/** Get the set of Rules that need to have manual delegations
	 *  like "void rule() { importedGrammar.rule(); }"
	 *
	 *  If this grammar is master, get list of all rule definitions from all
	 *  delegate grammars.  Only master has complete interface from combined
	 *  grammars...we will generated delegates as helper objects.
	 *
	 *  Composite grammars that are not the root/master do not have complete
	 *  interfaces.  It is not my intention that people use subcomposites.
	 *  Only the outermost grammar should be used from outside code.  The
	 *  other grammar components are specifically generated to work only
	 *  with the master/root.
	 *
	 *  delegatedRules = imported - overridden
	 */
	public Set<? extends Rule> getDelegatedRules() {
		return composite.getDelegatedRules(this);
	}

	/** Get set of all rules imported from all delegate grammars even if
	 *  indirectly delegated.
	 */
	public Set<? extends Rule> getAllImportedRules() {
		return composite.getAllImportedRules(this);
	}

	/** Get list of all delegates from all grammars directly or indirectly
	 *  imported into this grammar.
	 */
	public List<Grammar> getDelegates() {
		return composite.getDelegates(this);
	}

	public boolean getHasDelegates() {
	   return !getDelegates().isEmpty();
	}

	public List<String> getDelegateNames() {
		// compute delegates:{Grammar g | return g.name;}
		List<String> names = new ArrayList<String>();
		List<Grammar> delegates = composite.getDelegates(this);
		if ( delegates!=null ) {
			for (Grammar g : delegates) {
				names.add(g.name);
			}
		}
		return names;
	}

	public List<Grammar> getDirectDelegates() {
		return composite.getDirectDelegates(this);
	}

	/** Get delegates below direct delegates */
	public List<Grammar> getIndirectDelegates() {
		return composite.getIndirectDelegates(this);
	}

	/** Get list of all delegators.  This amounts to the grammars on the path
	 *  to the root of the delegation tree.
	 */
	public List<Grammar> getDelegators() {
		return composite.getDelegators(this);
	}

	/** Who's my direct parent grammar? */
	public Grammar getDelegator() {
		return composite.getDelegator(this);
	}

	public Set<Rule> getDelegatedRuleReferences() {
		return delegatedRuleReferences;
	}

	public boolean getGrammarIsRoot() {
		return composite.delegateGrammarTreeRoot.grammar == this;
	}

	public void setRuleAST(String ruleName, GrammarAST t) {
		Rule r = getLocallyDefinedRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			r.tree = t;
			r.EORNode = t.getLastChild();
		}
	}

	public NFAState getRuleStartState(String ruleName) {
		return getRuleStartState(null, ruleName);
	}

	public NFAState getRuleStartState(String scopeName, String ruleName) {
		Rule r = getRule(scopeName, ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			//System.out.println("getRuleStartState("+scopeName+", "+ruleName+")="+r.startState);
			return r.startState;
		}
		//System.out.println("getRuleStartState("+scopeName+", "+ruleName+")=null");
		return null;
	}

	public String getRuleModifier(String ruleName) {
		Rule r = getRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			return r.modifier;
		}
		return null;
	}

	public NFAState getRuleStopState(String ruleName) {
		Rule r = getRule(ruleName);
		if ( r!=null ) {
			return r.stopState;
		}
		return null;
	}

	public int assignDecisionNumber(NFAState state) {
		decisionCount++;
		state.setDecisionNumber(decisionCount);
		return decisionCount;
	}

	protected Decision getDecision(int decision) {
		int index = decision-1;
		if ( index >= indexToDecision.size() ) {
			return null;
		}
		Decision d = indexToDecision.get(index);
		return d;
	}

	public List<Decision> getDecisions() {
		return indexToDecision;
	}

	protected Decision createDecision(int decision) {
		int index = decision-1;
		if ( index < indexToDecision.size() ) {
			return getDecision(decision); // don't recreate
		}
		Decision d = new Decision();
		d.decision = decision;
		d.grammar = this;
		indexToDecision.setSize(getNumberOfDecisions());
		indexToDecision.set(index, d);
		return d;
	}

	public List<NFAState> getDecisionNFAStartStateList() {
		List<NFAState> states = new ArrayList<NFAState>(100);
		for (int d = 0; d < indexToDecision.size(); d++) {
			Decision dec = indexToDecision.get(d);
			states.add(dec.startState);
		}
		return states;
	}

	public NFAState getDecisionNFAStartState(int decision) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		if ( d==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		return d.startState;
	}

	public DFA getLookaheadDFA(int decision) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		if ( d==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		return d.dfa;
	}

	public GrammarAST getDecisionBlockAST(int decision) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		if ( d==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		return d.blockAST;
	}

	/** returns a list of column numbers for all decisions
	 *  on a particular line so ANTLRWorks choose the decision
	 *  depending on the location of the cursor (otherwise,
	 *  ANTLRWorks has to give the *exact* location which
	 *  is not easy from the user point of view).
	 *
	 *  This is not particularly fast as it walks entire line:col&rarr;DFA map
	 *  looking for a prefix of "line:".
	 */
	public List<Integer> getLookaheadDFAColumnsForLineInFile(int line) {
		String prefix = line+":";
		List<Integer> columns = new ArrayList<Integer>();
		for (String key : lineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap.keySet()) {
			if(key.startsWith(prefix)) {
				columns.add(Integer.valueOf(key.substring(prefix.length())));
			}
		}
		return columns;
	}

	/** Useful for ANTLRWorks to map position in file to the DFA for display */
	public DFA getLookaheadDFAFromPositionInFile(int line, int col) {
		return lineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap.get(
			new StringBuffer().append(line).append(":").append(col).toString());
	}

	public Map<String, DFA> getLineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap() {
		return lineColumnToLookaheadDFAMap;
	}

	/*
	public void setDecisionOptions(int decision, Map options) {
		Decision d = createDecision(decision);
		d.options = options;
	}

	public void setDecisionOption(int decision, String name, Object value) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		if ( d!=null ) {
			if ( d.options==null ) {
				d.options = new HashMap();
			}
			d.options.put(name,value);
		}
	}

	public Map getDecisionOptions(int decision) {
		Decision d = getDecision(decision);
		if ( d==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		return d.options;
    }
    */

	public int getNumberOfDecisions() {
		return decisionCount;
	}

	public int getNumberOfCyclicDecisions() {
		int n = 0;
		for (int i=1; i<=getNumberOfDecisions(); i++) {
			Decision d = getDecision(i);
			if ( d.dfa!=null && d.dfa.isCyclic() ) {
				n++;
			}
		}
		return n;
	}

	/** Set the lookahead DFA for a particular decision.  This means
	 *  that the appropriate AST node must updated to have the new lookahead
	 *  DFA.  This method could be used to properly set the DFAs without
	 *  using the createLookaheadDFAs() method.  You could do this
	 *
	 *    Grammar g = new Grammar("...");
	 *    g.setLookahead(1, dfa1);
	 *    g.setLookahead(2, dfa2);
	 *    ...
	 */
	public void setLookaheadDFA(int decision, DFA lookaheadDFA) {
		Decision d = createDecision(decision);
		d.dfa = lookaheadDFA;
		GrammarAST ast = d.startState.associatedASTNode;
		ast.setLookaheadDFA(lookaheadDFA);
	}

	public void setDecisionNFA(int decision, NFAState state) {
		Decision d = createDecision(decision);
		d.startState = state;
	}

	public void setDecisionBlockAST(int decision, GrammarAST blockAST) {
		//System.out.println("setDecisionBlockAST("+decision+", "+blockAST.token);
		Decision d = createDecision(decision);
		d.blockAST = blockAST;
	}

	public boolean allDecisionDFAHaveBeenCreated() {
		return allDecisionDFACreated;
	}

	/** How many token types have been allocated so far? */
	public int getMaxTokenType() {
		return composite.maxTokenType;
	}

	/** What is the max char value possible for this grammar's target?  Use
	 *  unicode max if no target defined.
	 */
	public int getMaxCharValue() {
		if ( generator!=null ) {
			return generator.target.getMaxCharValue(generator);
		}
		else {
			return Label.MAX_CHAR_VALUE;
		}
	}

	/** Return a set of all possible token or char types for this grammar */
	public IntSet getTokenTypes() {
		if ( type==LEXER ) {
			return getAllCharValues();
		}
		return IntervalSet.of(Label.MIN_TOKEN_TYPE, getMaxTokenType());
	}

	/** If there is a char vocabulary, use it; else return min to max char
	 *  as defined by the target.  If no target, use max unicode char value.
	 */
	public IntSet getAllCharValues() {
		if ( charVocabulary!=null ) {
			return charVocabulary;
		}
		IntSet allChar = IntervalSet.of(Label.MIN_CHAR_VALUE, getMaxCharValue());
		return allChar;
	}

	/** Return a string representing the escaped char for code c.  E.g., If c
	 *  has value 0x100, you will get "\u0100".  ASCII gets the usual
	 *  char (non-hex) representation.  Control characters are spit out
	 *  as unicode.  While this is specially set up for returning Java strings,
	 *  it can be used by any language target that has the same syntax. :)
	 *
	 *  11/26/2005: I changed this to use double quotes, consistent with antlr.g
	 *  12/09/2005: I changed so everything is single quotes
	 */
	public static String getANTLRCharLiteralForChar(int c) {
		if ( c<Label.MIN_CHAR_VALUE ) {
			ErrorManager.internalError("invalid char value "+c);
			return "'<INVALID>'";
		}
		if ( c<ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape.length && ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape[c]!=null ) {
			return '\''+ANTLRLiteralCharValueEscape[c]+'\'';
		}
		if ( Character.UnicodeBlock.of((char)c)==Character.UnicodeBlock.BASIC_LATIN &&
			 !Character.isISOControl((char)c) ) {
			if ( c=='\\' ) {
				return "'\\\\'";
			}
			if ( c=='\'') {
				return "'\\''";
			}
			return '\''+Character.toString((char)c)+'\'';
		}
		// turn on the bit above max "\uFFFF" value so that we pad with zeros
		// then only take last 4 digits
		String hex = Integer.toHexString(c|0x10000).toUpperCase().substring(1,5);
		String unicodeStr = "'\\u"+hex+"'";
		return unicodeStr;
	}

	/** For lexer grammars, return everything in unicode not in set.
	 *  For parser and tree grammars, return everything in token space
	 *  from MIN_TOKEN_TYPE to last valid token type or char value.
	 */
	public IntSet complement(IntSet set) {
		//System.out.println("complement "+set.toString(this));
		//System.out.println("vocabulary "+getTokenTypes().toString(this));
		IntSet c = set.complement(getTokenTypes());
		//System.out.println("result="+c.toString(this));
		return c;
	}

	public IntSet complement(int atom) {
		return complement(IntervalSet.of(atom));
	}

	/** Given set tree like ( SET A B ), check that A and B
	 *  are both valid sets themselves, else we must tree like a BLOCK
	 */
	public boolean isValidSet(TreeToNFAConverter nfabuilder, GrammarAST t) {
		boolean valid;
		try {
			//System.out.println("parse BLOCK as set tree: "+t.toStringTree());
			int alts = nfabuilder.testBlockAsSet(t);
			valid = alts > 1;
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			// The rule did not parse as a set, return null; ignore exception
			valid = false;
		}
		//System.out.println("valid? "+valid);
		return valid;
	}

	/** Get the set equivalent (if any) of the indicated rule from this
	 *  grammar.  Mostly used in the lexer to do ~T for some fragment rule
	 *  T.  If the rule AST has a SET use that.  If the rule is a single char
	 *  convert it to a set and return.  If rule is not a simple set (w/o actions)
	 *  then return null.
	 *  Rules have AST form:
	 *
	 *		^( RULE ID modifier ARG RET SCOPE block EOR )
	 */
	public IntSet getSetFromRule(TreeToNFAConverter nfabuilder, String ruleName)
		throws RecognitionException
	{
		Rule r = getRule(ruleName);
		if ( r==null ) {
			return null;
		}
		IntSet elements;
		//System.out.println("parsed tree: "+r.tree.toStringTree());
		elements = nfabuilder.setRule(r.tree);
		//System.out.println("elements="+elements);
		return elements;
	}

	/** Decisions are linked together with transition(1).  Count how
	 *  many there are.  This is here rather than in NFAState because
	 *  a grammar decides how NFAs are put together to form a decision.
	 */
	public int getNumberOfAltsForDecisionNFA(NFAState decisionState) {
		if ( decisionState==null ) {
			return 0;
		}
		int n = 1;
		NFAState p = decisionState;
		while ( p.transition[1] !=null ) {
			n++;
			p = (NFAState)p.transition[1].target;
		}
		return n;
	}

	/** Get the ith alternative (1..n) from a decision; return null when
	 *  an invalid alt is requested.  I must count in to find the right
	 *  alternative number.  For (A|B), you get NFA structure (roughly):
	 *
	 *  o-&gt;o-A-&gt;o
	 *  |
	 *  o-&gt;o-B-&gt;o
	 *
	 *  This routine returns the leftmost state for each alt.  So alt=1, returns
	 *  the upperleft most state in this structure.
	 */
	public NFAState getNFAStateForAltOfDecision(NFAState decisionState, int alt) {
		if ( decisionState==null || alt<=0 ) {
			return null;
		}
		int n = 1;
		NFAState p = decisionState;
		while ( p!=null ) {
			if ( n==alt ) {
				return p;
			}
			n++;
			Transition next = p.transition[1];
			p = null;
			if ( next!=null ) {
				p = (NFAState)next.target;
			}
		}
		return null;
	}

	/*
	public void computeRuleFOLLOWSets() {
		if ( getNumberOfDecisions()==0 ) {
			createNFAs();
		}
		for (Iterator it = getRules().iterator(); it.hasNext();) {
			Rule r = (Rule)it.next();
			if ( r.isSynPred ) {
				continue;
			}
			LookaheadSet s = ll1Analyzer.FOLLOW(r);
			System.out.println("FOLLOW("+r.name+")="+s);
		}
	}
	*/

	public LookaheadSet FIRST(NFAState s) {
		return ll1Analyzer.FIRST(s);
	}

	public LookaheadSet LOOK(NFAState s) {
		return ll1Analyzer.LOOK(s);
	}

	public void setCodeGenerator(CodeGenerator generator) {
		this.generator = generator;
	}

	public CodeGenerator getCodeGenerator() {
		return generator;
	}

	public GrammarAST getGrammarTree() {
		return grammarTree;
	}

	public void setGrammarTree(GrammarAST value) {
		grammarTree = value;
	}

	public Tool getTool() {
		return tool;
	}

	public void setTool(Tool tool) {
		this.tool = tool;
	}

	/** given a token type and the text of the literal, come up with a
	 *  decent token type label.  For now it's just T&lt;type&gt;.  Actually,
	 *  if there is an aliased name from tokens like PLUS='+', use it.
	 */
	public String computeTokenNameFromLiteral(int tokenType, String literal) {
		return AUTO_GENERATED_TOKEN_NAME_PREFIX +tokenType;
	}

	@Override
	public String toString() {
	//	return "FFFFFFFFFFFFFF";
		return grammarTreeToString(grammarTree);
	}

	public String grammarTreeToString(GrammarAST t) {
		return grammarTreeToString(t, true);
	}

	public String grammarTreeToString(GrammarAST t, boolean showActions) {
		String s;
		try {
			s = t.getLine()+":"+(t.getCharPositionInLine()+1)+": ";
			s += new ANTLRTreePrinter(new CommonTreeNodeStream(t)).toString(this, showActions);
		}
		catch (Exception e) {
			s = "<invalid or missing tree structure>";
		}
		return s;
	}

	public void printGrammar(PrintStream output) {
		ANTLRTreePrinter printer = new ANTLRTreePrinter(new CommonTreeNodeStream(getGrammarTree()));
		try {
			String g = printer.toString(this, false);
			output.println(g);
		}
		catch (RecognitionException re) {
			ErrorManager.error(ErrorManager.MSG_SYNTAX_ERROR,re);
		}
	}

}